The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[ACat]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=113976121&userid=85238&signature=vZJjiTXkxZFUy3U6VXpaow

How does this look for C$ to list items? I don't mind them being valued slightly lower as I know items are harder to trade off, I think it's about 5 MA in value for all of them

[Mariie]

Hello
This is probably super difficult to evaluate if possible at all, but approximately what would 9764 omg so common-extremely uncommon pets from 2024-2010 be valued at? (The pets in question are located here, I know it's a longshot but maybe someone is able to help)
And also which one of these is a better offer for them
One
Two
Thank you greatly for any help 🦋

And also what about this? Which of the 4 is the best one?
Three
Four
Thank you again 🦋

[Smincy]

Would you help me with this one for the moonswirl, please?
Thanks a lot in advance!



trades/viewtrade.php?id=113972755&userid=419&signature=FUk002epk_LytK2nYGNn9A

Maybe someone can help me with this one?

[texastoast]

Would you help me with this one for the moonswirl, please?
Thanks a lot in advance!



trades/viewtrade.php?id=113972755&userid=419&signature=FUk002epk_LytK2nYGNn9A

Maybe someone can help me with this one?

in old rares, your side is 2.5N, and theirs is worth 2.5N. It's fair, but the bulk of pets is not often traded that high up. In terms of c$, the moonswirl is worth 4.5k c$ and your pets are worth 6-8k c$, sop it'd be unfair to you if you decided to sell them for c$. It really depends on what you're looking for - a trade up, or to keep your pets.

[Smincy]

Thanks a lot! 🙏

[IlDottore]

I was offer 125 c$ for this - thoughts?

[i don't know her]

I was offer 125 c$ for this - thoughts?

You can probably get a lot more — based on the C$ buy/sell thread, I think $125 is on the higher end of 2018-2020 store pets with decent to good demand. That litter & dragons in general seem to have great demand and are from 2014, and even lower demand store pets from 2014 seem to be going for like $400+. This is, of course, personal opinion since C$ prices seem to be very subjective.

[texastoast]

I was offer 125 c$ for this - thoughts?

Don’t take it, their worth is a lot more in c$.

[ravemn]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=113978219&userid=194301&signature=7L5Ezp4GzYyPq83jCSh9iQ

is this fair? :o

[texastoast]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=113978219&userid=194301&signature=7L5Ezp4GzYyPq83jCSh9iQ

is this fair?

unfair to you -- your pets alone are worth 2x more c$ than theirs, even with their pet being true date. (260-300 c$ is your side roughly, or .6 MA in old rares). Their side is just one old rare. I didn't include the items, but it'd be unfair even without the items.