The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Demonking Urizen]

how bout this?

slighty unfair to them, considering 70 c$ is equal to a 09 vr
the bwolf wasn't necessary as the Valentine's Malk Cat is worth 4 '09 rares

Here's another trade I just got! I was wondering if this was fair??? Thank you so much!

unfair to you.
a 2019 store pet is worth an early 10 rare, so your side would be an early 09 rare
the 11 rare + recent rares aren't enough to close the gap
(which would be a late '10 - early 11 rare)

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95849044&userid=700638&signature=K88PVQUPs8j1k8mhzJGSVQ

I'm not sure if this is fair or not, item warning. x.x

looking at the popular items guide the blue scarf is worth 0.25n
their side is not even close to that

[Luggas]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=95957882&userid=989496&signature=-iZ-W2TBe4zFqiRQiKmGRQ

It's quite the old rare pet but the other one is a very rare store pet which are, as far as I heard, rather hard to find in general

[Tabelspoon]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95953568&userid=958735&signature=ON5tqSp78Ntsao2ZlIWOVA
Is this fair :0?

Thanks in advance !

[Geckos_N_Tea]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=95957882&userid=989496&signature=-iZ-W2TBe4zFqiRQiKmGRQ

It's quite the old rare pet but the other one is a very rare store pet which are, as far as I heard, rather hard to find in general

that is unfair to you. i’m pretty sure a 2021 store pet is worth a late 2010 rare (edit: i meant to say early xd) . and you are correct about them being harder to find as they get rarer, but for recent store pets this doesn’t increase the value of them. since they were bought for the same amount of c$ they are all worth the same :) (this doesn’t apply to older store pets)

[LavenderHaze]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=95957882&userid=989496&signature=-iZ-W2TBe4zFqiRQiKmGRQ

It's quite the old rare pet but the other one is a very rare store pet which are, as far as I heard, rather hard to find in general

that is unfair to you. i’m pretty sure a 2021 store pet is worth a late 2010 rare. and you are correct about them being harder to find as they get rarer, but for recent store pets this doesn’t increase the value of them. since they were bought for the same amount of c$ they are all worth the same (this doesn’t apply to older store pets)

The 2019 SP is worth an early 10 rare, so this is unfair for you.

[Spacepvp]

Would this be fair?
XX

[Kruziik]

Is this fair? I dont really know how to value 2021 store pets ngl-

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95958361&userid=789212&signature=Sj6JIRPrSx1Qcy2SmAhFww

[Caslixe]

this?

[lemon!!]

Is this fair? I dont really know how to value 2021 store pets ngl-

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95958361&userid=789212&signature=Sj6JIRPrSx1Qcy2SmAhFww

21 store pets are valued at anywhere from a mid 10 rare to an early 11 (though i don’t know anyone who would actually just accept that).
so with the commonly given values, unfair to them - but personally i would say that’s a good swap.

[Gelée Nova]

Hello! Could I please get anyone's opinion on this trade? *Slight bulk warning* From what I can tell, I believe their side adds up to around 4.5-4.75 nons give or take?? - Would just like someone else's insight other than my own ^^'
Thanks in advance for any advice! <3