The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[jinbad]

I know I had a similar trade sent to me a while ago, but after having the Coontail for a while, I'm beginning to want to try to cut my losses.

Would this be worth it? How easy is it to trade a UR Foal for 1.5 nons, or would I struggle as much as I am with trading this Coontail for the same amount? I know the foal goes for 1 non as well, but how much more compared to 1.5? I'd love to hear some advice on this. Thank you!

[Cynicat]

Link
I already accepted, but I was wondering if it was fair or not?

[nobxdy]

Link
I already accepted, but I was wondering if it was fair or not?

It was unfair to them
If you use the list, their 2012 store pet would be worth 3-4 '09 rares, your cat is only worth 2 '09 rares (was extended into August 2009). Even without the list, I still value their side around 5 '09 rares, so I still see it as unfair to them.
You're free to value your pets how you wish though!

[Spine]

pleaaaseee help!!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83934510&userid=973991&signature=PT85Yaxo6VJaSUPFBia96g

[Rbpuppy]

Link
I already accepted, but I was wondering if it was fair or not?

It was unfair to them
If you use the list, their 2012 store pet would be worth 3-4 '09 rares, your cat is only worth 2 '09 rares (was extended into August 2009). Even without the list, I still value their side around 5 '09 rares, so I still see it as unfair to them.
You're free to value your pets how you wish though!

I second this! The definitely over paid c:

[nobxdy]

pleaaaseee help!!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83934510&userid=973991&signature=PT85Yaxo6VJaSUPFBia96g

It's unfair to them
Their side = 2009 rare + 2011 rare + 2017 rare
Your side = 2010 rare + 2019 rare + the unknowns

[Cynicat]

Link
I already accepted, but I was wondering if it was fair or not?

It was unfair to them
If you use the list, their 2012 store pet would be worth 3-4 '09 rares, your cat is only worth 2 '09 rares (was extended into August 2009). Even without the list, I still value their side around 5 '09 rares, so I still see it as unfair to them.
You're free to value your pets how you wish though!

I second this! The definitely over paid c:

Good to know, thank you! I saw the alien dog and accepted without even looking at the other pets, so I just wanted to make sure lol.

[Jaax]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83934680&userid=833950&signature=Oe4EYM_bLQ9I86viHS3DKA
valuing the ur tiger dog at 6 nons would this be fair?
ty for your advice <3

[‍‍⠀]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83931010&userid=580861&signature=kKWxjsegO6lVOsron1XMyQ

is this fair? thanks!

[saint]

hi! could i get some help
with this trade please?
thank you!!