The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Xeroxoe]

xxx
Thoughts?

[EchothroughDarkness]

xxx
Thoughts?

I say its unfair to you, because they are asking for 2 09 pets and they are only giving I think a 2010 and possibly another 2010 if I remember the dates.

[Joof]

Is this trade fair??

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73147887&userid=410864&signature=wasy2n0X_MMuyXj-bJEt6A

Unfair to them. The UR bw is worth 3 nons and a purple tox. Your side adds up to a non (spotted tribal plus sorb) and about a UR purple horse (dark leo plus palomino tess horse). The BW tends to go for underpay (about two nons in value), but the stuff on your side also doesn't have the very best demand. In the end it's up to you what you do about demand, by rarity it's way unfair to the BW side (:

[myth;]

xxx
Thoughts?

I say its unfair to you, because they are asking for 2 09 pets and they are only giving I think a 2010 and possibly another 2010 if I remember the dates.

The orange wood dog is a 2009 rare from June, the other from June 2010. So their side is worth 1x 2011 short of 2x 2009 rares. I recommend adding another 2011 rare to their side and removing the 2014 from your's to make it fair.

Is this trade fair??

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73147887&userid=410864&signature=wasy2n0X_MMuyXj-bJEt6A

The UR Butterfly wolf is worth 3 nons, so by rarity it's unfair to them. Demand wise, it trades for anything between 1-3 nons, most often it's 2 or so.
Your side is worth just over a non and is unfair to them, though the spotted tribal can be tricky to trade down fairly. The Chicken Smoothie item is trading for about a 2010 rare, so it doesn't make a big impact to the overall trade.

[Maii ♥]

xx
fair?

[myth;]

xx
fair?

I'm sure someone answered this, or a trade very similar to this.
2008 rares, unless I'm mistaken, are worth 1x 2009 rare and 1x 2010 rare. So you're overpaying, I reocmmend removing one of the 2009 rares and the C$ or store pet.

[ℋoney]

could i get some help with these?
x x x

[myth;]

could i get some help with these?
x x x

1 = The PPS is a tier 11 September list and worth 48-64 2009 rares. Their side is worth 8x 2009 rares, the C$ worth a tier 12 September (dark leopard or black advent tier). Technically, the C$ is overpay enough, the rares aren't needed.

2 = The PPS Cocoon is worth 6-7 2009 rares and their side 7-8 overall. They're overpaying by 3-4 2009 rares, the draogn's demand however might decrease that number to 2-3 2009 rares.

3 = The palomino Tess horse is 5 tiers lower than the PPS, which leave a 15-24 2009 rare gap between the two pets. The 100C$ (worth a sockdog/10 2009 rares) does not cover it.

[zillywair]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73156505&userid=932854&signature=WgfXa1PAhjrNR7ScpUJUbg
id really like help asap, is this fair ??

[broccolibomp!]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73157228&userid=782848&signature=wgH-ukz1y9VdEBJ0yjisdAis this fair? could i get an opinion demand-wise and rarity-wise? thanks!