The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Paul.]

Hi guys! So, this trade, the person I'm trading with says that a Sunjewel gets about 3.25 as the "middle" value, and a liontail gets 2.75 nons in the "middle" value, and they're asking for the slightest amount of add. I've seen the liontail getting around 2.75-3 nons lately and the sunjewel getting around 2.5 nons. What exactly should I do here??

Here's the trade: xxx

[lemon.shark]

is this fair? :)

Okay, so the dog is from the 2013 slumber party event, and it's worth about 15-18c$. I'm just gonna convert all this to c$ for ease. The '16 is 8-10C$, and the '18 are 4-6C$ each. So, 26-32c$ on their side.

Overpay by about 11-18c$. However, without the c$ on their side (and using the 2:1 rule), you would be overpaying by a lot. Interesting how that works, lol.

Ignoring all that, though. I'd say this is pretty fair from my experience. Maybe just a bit of overpay on their side.

[Jiloon]

Hi guys! So, this trade, the person I'm trading with says that a Sunjewel gets about 3.25 as the "middle" value, and a liontail gets 2.75 nons in the "middle" value, and they're asking for the slightest amount of add. I've seen the liontail getting around 2.75-3 nons lately and the sunjewel getting around 2.5 nons. What exactly should I do here??

Here's the trade: xxx

The Sunjewel is worth the 3-3.5 but really only gets 2.5 of higher demand pets, 3 of lower demand. The Liontails consistently swap for 3n, so personally I wouldn't take it if I were you. The Liontails are much easier to trade off fairly

[backstabbed]

Hi guys! So, this trade, the person I'm trading with says that a Sunjewel gets about 3.25 as the "middle" value, and a liontail gets 2.75 nons in the "middle" value, and they're asking for the slightest amount of add. I've seen the liontail getting around 2.75-3 nons lately and the sunjewel getting around 2.5 nons. What exactly should I do here??

Here's the trade: xxx

Lion tail has better demand then Sunjewel, but sunjewel gets 3-3.5 nons pretty normally

[abbie.]

could i get an opinion on these trades?
x
(non-ballon for merle corgi, light leopard & blue rose)

x
(emerald butterfly wolf(?) for merle corgi

x
(royal-bobtail for merle corgi)

x
(various rares & some c$ for blue rose)

i’m 99% sure the first one is fair but i just wanted to double check it, unsure about the others though
thank you in advance!!

[Paul.]

Hello again! Im here with a different trade!!

Im not too sure what to think of this one, but I'd like to have opinions!

Here it is!: xxx

[Paul.]

( did not mean to bump, so sorry!)

[( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°]

Hello again! Im here with a different trade!!

Im not too sure what to think of this one, but I'd like to have opinions!

Here it is!: xxx

That seems pretty fair to me in my opinion, sure the sunjewel doesn't have the best demand but from what Is but the liontails are worth 2.75-3 nons, the sunjewel is 3-3.5 nons but (goes for lower) plus the nontag, thats pretty fair I believe but get a second opinion!

[patriciaツ]

hi! i haven't played actively for the last few years and i just got two trades for my td ba and i was wondering if anyone had any advice? thank you:)

1. https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97917413&userid=573841&signature=YtjMgldoXQ6OGxSBKZQRvg
2. https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97914693

[darling feathers]

could i have an opinion on this trade? c:
feathers