The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Frozen_Cherry]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92583550&userid=725461&signature=Z-IajSAgY4peKf5qaT-qpQ

also they said this when i asked them to add:

im sorry i get that yours are from a earlier date but i have 4 pets on here and one of your pets is only an omg so common and the uncommon is getting offered 3 pets so its rllu up to u to cancel or accept!

[starna]

hello! any thoughts on this trade? it's a pet on my wishlist that i want but i'm not sure if its worth it?
thank you!

[Deerdancer]

Items and C$ make this trade confusing. Is it good?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92591953&userid=203847&signature=GMNQGJfag_lxptH9I23fPA

[kapetrovaa]

hello!
could I please have an opinion
or two on this trade please?
thank you

i think you can get much more for the full set, the irl dog set tends to get alot for the litter mates alone. im not sure what the full woth would be for the full set but this is unfair to you.

thank you so much
does anyone know what they can fetch please?

[northnorthwest]

I have no idea what shimas go for. Is 3 MA for a true date shima longtail about right? It sounds like a lot, but I haven't been paying much attention to Shima demand.
Also I think laptop=1 MA is the accepted value, is that right?

[Strawberry_dreams]

I have no idea what shimas go for. Is 3 MA for a true date shima longtail about right? It sounds like a lot, but I haven't been paying much attention to Shima demand.
Also I think laptop=1 MA is the accepted value, is that right?

yes, the trade is fair. but id personally keep the T7's

[Rbpuppy]

Hey there! I'm not the best at these types of trades would someone help out? The trade is below↓↓↓
XXX

This is perfectly fair as both pets are 2010 Rares. Demand is up to you so whichever pet you prefer

[kapetrovaa]

hello! any advice is appreciated
sunjewel + ur kirin + purple toxic = ur tiger?
it's around fair I believe just for rarity -
what about demand and tradeability?

thank you

[ellebee]

hello! any advice is appreciated
sunjewel + ur kirin + purple toxic = ur tiger?
it's around fair I believe just for rarity -
what about demand and tradeability?

thank you

their side is a little under. The tiger goes for around 6 nons recently considering demand. The UR Kirin has a fluctuatnig rarity and value, since it's a relatively new UR, but recent trade data shows that it goes for around 1.5-2 nons. The Sunjewel commonly goes for 2.5-3 nons, and the purple toxic goes for around 0.5 nons. So this is 4.5-5.5 nons , on either side of this range, they're under.

Resources Used
Condensed CS Rarity List
VR and OMGSR Successful Trades

[Howl's Moving Castle]

hello! any advice is appreciated
sunjewel + ur kirin + purple toxic = ur tiger?
it's around fair I believe just for rarity -
what about demand and tradeability?

thank you

their side is a little under. The tiger goes for around 6 nons recently considering demand. The UR Kirin has a fluctuatnig rarity and value, since it's a relatively new UR, but recent trade data shows that it goes for around 1.5-2 nons. The Sunjewel commonly goes for 2.5-3 nons, and the purple toxic goes for around 0.5 nons. So this is 4.5-5.5 nons , on either side of this range, they're under.

Resources Used
Condensed CS Rarity List
VR and OMGSR Successful Trades

um this is incorrect. sumjewel goes for 3-3.5 it been backed up by alot of sources. as shown below. it never gets 2.5, the minimum is always been 3. the list you have doesnt give correct values of urs all the time, so that is probably why you were confused with worth. also kirin gets normally 2 but it has been dipping to 1.75 as shown in the other 2 sources below. so with the purple toxic worth .5 that 5.25-6.
Forum/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=4461620&hilit=demanded
Forum/search.php?keywords=sunjewel&t=4460390&sf=msgonly

Forum/search.php?keywords=kirin&t=4460390&sf=msgonly
Forum/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=4461620&hilit=demanded