The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Ava Ire]

Hello, is this fair?

[yaksha]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73938080&userid=720831&signature=G45SHXT5TUTxQX5713iWWQ

Is this fair and would you accept? Does the Zonkey go for easy trades??

[ImThatRogue]

Hey! How's this trade? Thanks a bunch! <3
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73938192&userid=858758&signature=XrRgo-5RWcloPzfkPEMTxA

Without taking any demand into account, their side adds up to be worth about a speckled rat, so it's quite unfair to you. Your grapes are technically worth about 4x the value of their side. However, most of the pets on their side do have good demand and often go for more than they're actually worth, so it's up to you whether or not you want to accept based on what you value those pets at.

Can someone give me a second opinion ♥ Thank you! ~

Link: XXX

It's rather unfair to them, since your side adds up to just a scarf pps. Even taking into account the demand of the pets on your side, they're overpaying by quite a lot.

could i get an opinion
on this ? XXX thank you
for any help given !

The cinnabun doesn't have a set placement on the list yet, however I believe it's been going for anywhere between a non to UR aussie, so it seems like a good trade to me. Their side is worth about a UR lion or so.

This trade seems unfair to the person offering, but I think the shadow creatures are worth more? Opinions? I don't want to rip someone off.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73932300&userid=54333&signature=77TuClzsiN5sXRs9pLTgIA

Thanks for any help!

I believe the shadow creatures are worth a '10 rare or so now, but I see them going for '09 rares pretty often since they're pretty popular. Not sure what the ghost collar is worth, since I've actually never seen it until now, surprisingly, and it's the only collar I'm missing from that Halloween '10 set. However, if we're valuing the shadow creature at a '10 or '09 rare, I don't think the ghost collar would be worth the rest of the pets they're offering, so I believe they're overpaying. You may want to get another opinion from a more experienced item trader, though. I'm not much of an item trader.

Hello, is this fair?

Your side adds up to a little more than a skeleton pps, so it's unfair to them. However, you have a nice quantity of lists and older rares on your side that are likely easier to trade away than the UR apple. They are overpaying, though, so it's up to you whether or not you want to accept.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73938080&userid=720831&signature=G45SHXT5TUTxQX5713iWWQ

Is this fair and would you accept? Does the Zonkey go for easy trades??

Your side adds up to about a sorbet or so under a coontail. The zonkey doesn't have a place on the list yet, so it's up to you and how high you value it, but I believe it's been going for about 1.5-2 nons or so. Seems like a pretty good trade, but if you aren't going to be keeping the zonkey, I think it'd be easier to trade off your quantity. You may want another opinion, though, since I'm not 100% sure what the zonkey goes for nowadays.

[Ava Ire]

Hello, is this fair?

Your side adds up to a little more than a skeleton pps, so it's unfair to them. However, you have a nice quantity of lists and older rares on your side that are likely easier to trade away than the UR apple. They are overpaying, though, so it's up to you whether or not you want to accept.

Thank you!


I've just received another trade: Is this fair?

[ImThatRogue]

Thank you!

I've just received another trade: Is this fair?

Your side is still worth just a little more than a skeleton pps, so it's unfair to them.

[Shy_Insight]

I think this is good, but second opinon?

And this one

Thank you for any help!

[ImThatRogue]

I think this is good, but second opinon?

And this one

Thank you for any help!

1. Unfair to you. Their side adds up to be worth a little less than a '14 uncommon.

2. Also unfair to you. Their side adds up to be worth a little more than a '14 uncommon.

[Shy_Insight]

I think this is good, but second opinon?

And this one

Thank you for any help!

1. Unfair to you. Their side adds up to be worth a little less than a '14 uncommon.

2. Also unfair to you. Their side adds up to be worth a little more than a '14 uncommon.

Ah! Thank you! I was wrong! I appreciate the help! What would they need to add to even it out?

[ImThatRogue]

I think this is good, but second opinon?

And this one

Thank you for any help!

1. Unfair to you. Their side adds up to be worth a little less than a '14 uncommon.

2. Also unfair to you. Their side adds up to be worth a little more than a '14 uncommon.

Ah! Thank you! I was wrong! I appreciate the help! What would they need to add to even it out?

Anytime. <3

The first one would have to add '13, '14, and '17 uncommons. The second one would have to add '13, '15, and '17 uncommons. If you don't want to be that strict with the math, just add a few '13 commons or so and they should be fair.

[houndjaw]

I'm thinking this is pretty fair, but I'd like some opinions first