The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[BlossomTail]

I'm back with a new trade.

From them:


From me:

Unfair to the '08 Fox Advent Dog ^-^
I would add. . .to their side probably a few more '09 Rares in that case (:

Edit: Also, as Devilish suggested, please don't double post on this forum ^-^
There's an edit button you may use to solve that problem (:

[Devilish]

I'm back with a new trade.

From them:


From me:

I believe unfair to you..[Please don't double post^^]

[Lighty]

I'm back with a new trade.

From them:


From me:

It seems pretty fair but maybe a little bit unfair to the fox advent

[JadeiteWren]

I'm back with a new trade.

From them:


From me:

It seems pretty fair but maybe a little bit unfair to the fox advent

No. It's not even close to fair for the Fox Advent. :<

[emmaline]

Sorry Devilish, I thought I checked the last page but it was actually a few pages back.

As for

I'm back with a new trade.

From them:


From me:

The only other pet they have that I really want, other than commons, is this:

That PPS is "very rare" and I don't know exactly how rare that is in comparison, but I'm thinking it would be unfair for them even if they are willing to trade it. Any opinions? And thank you all so much for helping.

[supercrown]

the july PPS are worth alot.
like, ALOT

[Lighty]

I'm back with a new trade.

From them:


From me:

It seems pretty fair but maybe a little bit unfair to the fox advent

No. It's not even close to fair for the Fox Advent. :<

oh sorry

[BlossomTail]

The only other pet they have that I really want, other than commons, is this:

That PPS is "very rare" and I don't know exactly how rare that is in comparison, but I'm thinking it would be unfair for them even if they are willing to trade it. Any opinions? And thank you all so much for helping.

Definitely unfair for them if they want the Fox Advent. . .
The July PPS is worth a Coontail Dog, so yes, its completely unfair, lol.

[sd_dreamcrystal]

not fair, take away the green st. patricks day dog.

I'm not sure about that. You were able to get those Dec. Dogs all month, and the cats, only a day.

hrm, so which would you guys suggest I remove from my side or keep both on my side? (Where my post is)

[emmaline]

I was afraid of that, lol. Dang, I really want that lion and every trade with him seems to fall through. Thanks so much for your help, guys, I really really appreciate it. I'd be lost without this thread.