"Is this a fair trade?" Thread [Updated Dec 2019]

[executable]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86195511&userid=206927&signature=RcsKVE3SissCEx2uvKjhuQ


This is a bid for an auction! Just checking to see if I have a chance with all my savings xD

Nope. No list pets in your bid.

[eufemia]

I’m having trouble deciding if this is fair or not? I’m not that good with pet worth or the math that goes into fair trades 😅

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86194955&userid=978798&signature=GjeG-WbvHvewWo3wbSb97A

[wildwolfspiret]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86195511&userid=206927&signature=RcsKVE3SissCEx2uvKjhuQ


This is a bid for an auction! Just checking to see if I have a chance with all my savings xD

Even with considering the fluffy dog store set at a high September / low main this is highly unfair to the UR Tiger, unless I missed a list pet.

I have the blue alien store dog, Rudolph rat, and pink cookie there too xP

[Demonking Urizen]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86195511&userid=206927&signature=RcsKVE3SissCEx2uvKjhuQ


This is a bid for an auction! Just checking to see if I have a chance with all my savings xD

Nope. No list pets in your bid.

Please do not give false advice. There are list pets in the bid, but they aren't valuable enough to cover the 5? 6? Nons the UR Tiger is going for right now.

[executable]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86195511&userid=206927&signature=RcsKVE3SissCEx2uvKjhuQ


This is a bid for an auction! Just checking to see if I have a chance with all my savings xD

Nope. No list pets in your bid.

Please do not give false advice. There are list pets in the bid, but they aren't valuable enough to cover the 5? 6? Nons the UR Tiger is going for right now.

Not false advice if it’s not enough to cover it anyway, though.

[Rbpuppy]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86195033&userid=42960&signature=d1Sa9RyWRdRbitH86jCXPA

Not sure how much the NJ Liontail goes for, so any opinions on this? Thanks!

[wildwolfspiret]

[/quote="executable"][/quote="Rat King Hargrove"][/quote="executable"]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86195511&userid=206927&signature=RcsKVE3SissCEx2uvKjhuQ


This is a bid for an auction! Just checking to see if I have a chance with all my savings xD

Nope. No list pets in your bid.[/quote]

Please do not give false advice. There are list pets in the bid, but they aren't valuable enough to cover the 5? 6? Nons the UR Tiger is going for right now.[/quote]
Not false advice if it’s not enough to cover it anyway, though.
Technically the list doesn’t exist now sooooo.....

[amarok.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86195511&userid=206927&signature=RcsKVE3SissCEx2uvKjhuQ


This is a bid for an auction! Just checking to see if I have a chance with all my savings xD

Nope. No list pets in your bid.

Please do not give false advice. There are list pets in the bid, but they aren't valuable enough to cover the 5? 6? Nons the UR Tiger is going for right now.

Not false advice if it’s not enough to cover it anyway, though.

It is false advice. Hargrove did not say it was a fair offer, they said you're giving poor reasoning for what you're saying.
You said there's no list pets there when I counted a solid 7 list pets. You cannot say that kind of thing when it obviously isn't true and could lead to somebody getting scammed out of valuable pets, especially since all of those ex list pets continue to trade for OR ABOVE their list placement.
There's also pets (slight older stores) which frequently obtain a list value such as the robot cat store pet. Please make sure you're doing some research before you give answers, mate.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86195033&userid=42960&signature=d1Sa9RyWRdRbitH86jCXPA

Not sure how much the NJ Liontail goes for, so any opinions on this? Thanks!

People quote 2-3 nons for the liontails but I can't see the price going much higher for a good while yet. They're only worth around a non (if that, depending on how exactly you define a non) and they're not going to become unobtainable for long while yet as they only increase in value/worth in proportion to the number of active accounts increasing. If you're looking to trade this pet on later, I would not recommend this trade. However if you're looking to keep this pet in your collection and are willing to risk not necessarily getting 3 nons back if you ever do decide to trade it it would be considered fair demand wise. Just depends on how much you are personally willing to pay for this boi.

[atlos]

Is the hollyfox valued the same as a vixen? Would it be a fair trade? Thanks!

[Demonking Urizen]

Is the hollyfox valued the same as a vixen? Would it be a fair trade? Thanks!

Fair swap imo as both are a mid advent and go for overpay.