The "Is this a fair trade" Thread

[Topsy Turvey]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=68573734&userid=26641&signature=V_RlV-N8RYOEg7ZohZ0wpw

I have sent this but just wondering if it's okay, the dino demand is quite high

That is a major overpay. Personally, I don't think the demand is that high

Neither do I, overpay would be at max an 09 rare.

[rookie rook]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=68573734&userid=26641&signature=V_RlV-N8RYOEg7ZohZ0wpw

I have sent this but just wondering if it's okay, the dino demand is quite high

That is a major overpay. Personally, I don't think the demand is that high

Neither do I, overpay would be at max an 09 rare.

I agree, the dino doesn't really have that high demand. I got it with a fair trade on my second try of trying to get it.

[Charizard !]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... cKvTob21dQ Ahh idk??

[rookie rook]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=68573814&userid=839319&signature=j3MRN9eHbz_UcKvTob21dQ Ahh idk??

Rarity wise, not fair. They'd have to offer a 2010 rare to make it somewhat fair (2014 store = late 2009; 2015 store = early 2010). Demand wise, I think so..? I'm terrible with demand so maybe get a second opinion?

[kaiserbakura]

Is this trade fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=68574322&userid=901965&signature=pZ6EfqA1-kIH7M4jvStoTQ

[RationalParanoia]

LINK
I'm horrid when it comes to mixed rarity in regards to UCs & Rs - can I get a little help please?

EDIT: thank you for the help, smør

[shisho]

LINK
I'm horrid when it comes to mixed rarity in regards to UCs & Rs - can I get a little help please?

your 2013 uncommon is enough for the rare, it's up to you if you want to accept it or not tho

[PinkiiChan]

is this a fair trade? '-'

also:
ur cucumber + ??? = moonswirl

any opinions on that?

the other side is asking for 7-8 nons (including demand of your pets)
the moonswirl is only worth 4 nons so unfair to you.
second question - the cucumber goes for only a non so you need to add 3 nons.

thank you sm!!

any other opinions ?

[qhost]

These are my current top bids for two of my auctions;

Shima longtail
2011 Gryphon set

I'm fairly certain these are fair/overpay, but I wanted to double check before the auctions end tomorrow.
Thanks!

[Elorwin]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=68550302&userid=380379&signature=nxA2-8K9wLGPfoXFxq-J5g

Please can someone help. What do I need to add to make this work? I'm not great with the rarity lists.