The "Is this a fair trade" Thread

[Zombilon]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... JQ9gWXkYzQ

Fair?

No, they are worth about a 09 rare each if I am correct,

Thank you! Second opinion?

And how about this one?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... l1DP0EDN8w

2016 store pet = mid 2010 rare.
2014 store pet = late 2009 rare.
So it would technically be fair for your 2014, but your 2016 is overpay. Though I wouldn't accept it for the 2014 because ponies have low demand and it is easier to trade off the store pets.

And the other trade is unfair to you since it doesn't equal a late 2009 rare.

[Azey]

I haven't been on in a few years so i've forgotten a lot about trading e-e

c:

[Zombilon]

I haven't been on in a few years so i've forgotten a lot about trading e-e

c:

Your pet is a grown white scarf dog (advent list tier 1) worth three to four 2009 rares. The top adds up to about one 2009 rares + 2014 rare + two 2014 uncommons. Unfair to you. ^^
(Edit: accidentally typed two instead of one lol;
Two 2017 store pets = one 2009 rare.
Two 2016 rares = one 2015 rare.
Two 2015 rares (taking the value of the 2016 rares) = one 2014 rare).

[Inudragon]

I'v been here for a while, but haven't until recently gotten into trading pets. I was wondering if this trade is worth it? I'm not the best when it comes to valuing past event pets;;

Boop

[fallen;]

Hey there! Is this trade fair? They sent it to me and I'm not very good with item trades.

Thank you!

[Zombilon]

I'v been here for a while, but haven't until recently gotten into trading pets. I was wondering if this trade is worth it? I'm not the best when it comes to valuing past event pets;;

Boop

Their 2011 uncommon alone is overpay for your side due to the date differences. ^^

[Santa Sue]

I haven't been on in a few years so i've forgotten a lot about trading e-e

c:

Your pet is a grown white scarf dog (advent list tier 1) worth three to four 2009 rares. The top adds up to about two 2009 rares + 2014 rare + two 2014 uncommons. Unfair to you. ^^

I disagree, it's unfair to them yes, but I don't think their side adds up to more than two '09 rares, each of the 2017 store pets is only worth a '10 rare, and even if two '10 rares equals one '09 rare, the other pets don't add up to much more than a early '14-late '13 rare in my opinion, so equaling a total of 1 '09 rare and 1 '13-14 rare.

I'v been here for a while, but haven't until recently gotten into trading pets. I was wondering if this trade is worth it? I'm not the best when it comes to valuing past event pets;;

Boop

they are overpaying, a '11 uncommon is worth more than a '14 and a '15 uncommon, but you'll have to get another opinion on what else would need to be added.

[Aviator06]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... EjilZE71LA

Is this fair? Just double checking. I thought it was okay, but just in case.

[Horror]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=68572936&userid=619341&signature=BXT4AR7Eb8jgEjilZE71LA

Is this fair? Just double checking. I thought it was okay, but just in case.

All the pets in the trade were extended into August 09 and thus worth a mid-late 09 rare each. The trade was pretty much fair

[Rinsea]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=68572936&userid=619341&signature=BXT4AR7Eb8jgEjilZE71LA

Is this fair? Just double checking. I thought it was okay, but just in case.

fair rarity wise but the pups on their side have a higher demand than the purple dogs on yours