The "Is this a fair Trade?" thread.

[Shai]

The evil shima non pps for my rare green butterfly wolf?

If you own the butterwolf, the offer is not good, as the non-PPS may come out again.

[Earthbound]

oh ok, thanks guys. I hold on to my b-wolf =]

[Coalchaser]

Green sorbet, Green toxic, Sunback sundog

for

Yellow sorbet, Yellow toxic, line tribal, clear eyed galaxy


I need LOTS of advice QUICK

I think the person getting the green sorbet, green toxic, and sunback is getting a better deal.
The sorbets have essentially the same rarity, but the green toxic is rarer than the yellow toxic, and the sunback is (in my opinion anyways...) rarer than a line tribal and clear eyed galaxy combined.

I think you should get someone else's opinion, too, though. ^^"

[Scarlett.]

What sort of pets would be fair when asking for this pet: ? Someone had it in their trade group and I don't know what sort of pets would be fair to give them. Would just another color of that dog be fair or what? I want to make a fair trade that they will like as well as me. =)

i don't think another colour for the green is fair cause the green dog is the rarest for all the colour dogs .....

in my opinion , i should think that you should offer another rare for it . but i think u should ask others for the correct answer . ( in case mine is wrong )

[Celestial]

Yeah i agree, and i do know what your saying. what about a yellow toxic, clear eyed, and a blue balloon for the sunback?


EDIT: yellow sorbet, pink grinner, and a black/white 08 advent

for

line tribal


???

Totaly unfair. Even a sorbet for a line tribal is overpaying =)

[Scarlett.]

My Side : Ice Shima PPS OR three Uncommon dragons that grew from eggs ( he asked me to choose either one of the offers )

Their Side : two Uncommon bunnies ( the brown and yellow ones ) and two Common horses from Octobor

is it fair ???

ops , i almost forgot , he had a message that says : please,i would realy like these 3,just tell me what you you want{note: chose 2 more commmons or 1 uncommon,and the one with the purple stripe down its back is off limits}

if i DON'T choose 2 more commmons or 1 uncommon , will the trade be fair ?

if i DID choose 2 more commmons or 1 uncommon , will the trade be fair ?

[dozy]

I got a trade, but I dunno .___.

http://i45.tinypic.com/ehm3nm.jpg

Fair?

[Enbizaka]

I got a trade, but I dunno .___.

http://i45.tinypic.com/ehm3nm.jpg

Fair?

That looks, kinda fair. Plus, you get squiddy xD

[Tif + Jo]

Lunabelle: That looks pretty fair to me, especially since there were plenty of the kiss PPS back when they were out.

Correrre: I've had a couple julies (A Green sorbert and a black-eyed July) offered for my sunback, tempting yes, but I didn't accept. So I'm guessing that the value of a sunback is something worth around that area.

[haylin]

Theire 2nd-gen with the candy cane on the blancket

Mine Pink happy birthday pet from Sorren Fey (From Januari)?Faire/not fair and for who?