The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Rose Sinclair]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... beZkrQm-bw
Is this fair?
Thank you for any and all help I get ^^

[Centri]

Does this look ok?
Do sunjewels regularly go for a bit more than 5 nons, or are they hard to get "full price" for? Or, in other words, do they have good demand?

[Gwenfoxe]

Ooh, new thread. XD

Now, which one of these trades is the most overpay? I'm having an auction, and I want to know which is best, demand and rarity wise.

Bid one
Bid two
Bid three

[styx]

Is this fair? c:

[Opalide]

Does this look ok?
Do sunjewels regularly go for a bit more than 5 nons, or are they hard to get "full price" for? Or, in other words, do they have good demand?

The trade is unfair to you; and you're better off with the Moonswirl from what I've seen.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=33648687&userid=441792&signature=V8JFoPRT524TbeZkrQm-bw
Is this fair?
Thank you for any and all help I get ^^

Very unfair to you

[Centri]

Does this look ok?
Do sunjewels regularly go for a bit more than 5 nons, or are they hard to get "full price" for? Or, in other words, do they have good demand?

The trade is unfair to you; and you're better off with the Moonswirl from what I've seen.

Yep, I know that it is technically unfair, but since the cucumber does not have too great demand I thought it might be closer to "fair" demandwise.
Thank you for your input, I was not sure if the sunjewel had more or less demand than the moonswirl

[Rose Sinclair]

Ooh, new thread. XD

Now, which one of these trades is the most overpay? I'm having an auction, and I want to know which is best, demand and rarity wise.

Bid one
Bid two
Bid three

I would go with the third if i were you ^^

Is this a fair bid? Thanks in advance. c:

No, because their pet is a list pet and you are not offering any list pets in return.

Does this look ok?
Do sunjewels regularly go for a bit more than 5 nons, or are they hard to get "full price" for? Or, in other words, do they have good demand?

I do believe you are overpaying, but the sunjewl does have amazing demand!

(I am very sorry if any of my help was wrong, it is my opinion and what I would do if I received that trade.)



@Technicolour Kiwi
Thank you for your advice!

[Centri]

Does this look ok?
Do sunjewels regularly go for a bit more than 5 nons, or are they hard to get "full price" for? Or, in other words, do they have good demand?

I do believe you are overpaying, but the sunjewl does have amazing demand!

(I am very sorry if any of my help was wrong, it is my opinion and what I would do if I received that trade.)

Thank you, every opinion helps

[Gwenfoxe]

Ooh, new thread. XD

Now, which one of these trades is the most overpay? I'm having an auction, and I want to know which is best, demand and rarity wise.

Bid one
Bid two
Bid three

I would go with the third if i were you ^^

Thank you! Second opinion? I know the malk dragons have a lot of demand.

[MyNiallBear]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... U9OTrHqwmQ
fair?