The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[inulmori]

looking for help on a couple trades!

1: not exactly sure if the demand adds up :,)

2: boop!

3: not sure what the warriors as a whole go for, also rusty on non/ma worths and such :,)

[Piera]

Which of these is the better trade down?
Bid 1
Bid 2

[wolf'srain-toboe]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=115660428&userid=45799&signature=zCKGjsCQ-G41-1E7rbJVeg

[reefspeef]

thoughts on this? not good with items, thanks for any feedback!

[ssnowify]

is this fair?

[da,]

is this fair?

unfair to zonkey - rr august pps is 1.5n, zonkey is 2n

[kaiivy]

is this fair?
id be fine if it was a swap (2020 rare for 2022 rare) but the addition of the 2024 rare makes it feel unbalanced
trades/viewtrade.php?id=115708149&userid=768719&signature=A31bVgSJNMNPoo1jDwb2Ew

[Pastel-Axle]

Is this fair?? I’ve been seeking the pet on their side for a long, long time but I don’t know a whole lot about trading bulk ;v;

[Audrey_Bee]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=115617902&userid=604557&signature=SsiMjWjhzHQgrxUPH8gLXg

Need help calculating their side on this trade pls ❤️

sheesh, bulk rares 😰 i took everything from horrors guide! <3

(in no order) their side:
darkstripe = .5ma
red beta = .25ma
blue beta = .25ma
yellow and teal beta = .25ma
gray pps = ~.25ma
(tier 8, line 4) swirl valentine gupps = ~.3ma
all 2010 rares together = .25ma
all 2011 rares together = .4-.5ma
all 2013 rares together = ~40 c$ (can be less due to rat)
all 2021 rares together = ~24 c$
green 3rd gen = .3ma
king of spades lion = .5ma
flame tabby dog = .3ma
scribble dog - .3ma
(tier 5, line 7) brown spotted cookie = 1ma
just glancing over the under rare pets, i believe it should equal about 1-2 10'-11' rares!

so their total = 5.25ma, or .5nons! <3

my brain is shutting off, so please get a second opinion! its friday and my math is not too reliable rn :")

Thank you so much, you are a legend ! ❤️
Anyone else able to give the second opinion to double check ?:)

[Pastel-Axle]

is this fair?
id be fine if it was a swap (2020 rare for 2022 rare) but the addition of the 2024 rare makes it feel unbalanced
trades/viewtrade.php?id=115708149&userid=768719&signature=A31bVgSJNMNPoo1jDwb2Ew

I think this one depends on personal preference? I’ve seen quite a few people use the 2-year rule nowadays so on that basis it’s fair, but maybe they feel that they’d want a little extra on your end to try to make up the difference in years? Please get a second opinion, but I don’t know if this trade is super clear-cut ;v;