The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Sharkpop]

i was always gonna post this trade here but it got accepted like two seconds after i started having second thoughts
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=115704282&userid=977279&signature=793FnM5v_q6w4slf3SI-tg
i made im not very good with rarities, esp with dates and im praying i didnt just overtrade without knowing... (‘• x •`ᵕ )

[inzo]

i go inactive pretty frequently and don't trade much, can someone tell me if this trade is fair?

[Beratuna]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=115705805&userid=745368&signature=zBUeE-5FOPlUP9tgkoHCBQ

plsss help with this!!

[jprspereira]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=115705805&userid=745368&signature=zBUeE-5FOPlUP9tgkoHCBQ

plsss help with this!!

This is unfair to you. They're offering 4.5MA or 45 rares 2010/2011 for your 10MA pet or 100 rares 2010/2011.

[Piera]

Which of these is the better trade down?
Bid 1
Bid 2

[dwaekki]

i go inactive pretty frequently and don't trade much, can someone tell me if this trade is fair?

this is unfair to you! they would either have to add another 2021 uncommon or replace both with a 2021 very uncommon. but due to species demand, they may be asking for an overpay. lions, especially pps, are higher valued than the dwarfs!

i was always gonna post this trade here but it got accepted like two seconds after i started having second thoughts
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=115704282&userid=977279&signature=793FnM5v_q6w4slf3SI-tg
i made im not very good with rarities, esp with dates and im praying i didnt just overtrade without knowing... (‘• x •`ᵕ )

yeah.. this was definitely an overpay on your end ^^"

Just got this offer for one of the 19’ foxes, and while I’m feeling pretty dubious considering I vaguely know these have some sort of demand, I wanted to get someone else’s opinion.

Edit! Just got another trade for the fox that I would appreciate an opinion on!

for the 1st trade:

your side: vine fox = ranges from .25-.5ma

your total = ~150 c$ or .5ma (on the higher end)

their side =
cockatrice (idk rare pets names loll) = around 20-25 c$ due to high(ish) demand
all random pets = ~22'-24' rare
items are random and are close to no value

their total = worth about ~43 c$

so this is unfair to you! adding onto that, the fae foxes are getting decent overpays atm. they're not insanely sought after, but many people do like them! (you can see trade data in the link, though it is not recent)

-

for the 2nd trade:

your side: vine fox = ranges from .25-.5ma

your total = ~150 c$ or .5ma (on the higher end)

their side:
2011 rare dog (is there like an updated list for all the names??) - around 30 c$
random pets = about a 2024 euc

their total = around ~34 c$

so this is also unfair to you!!

[Animooser]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=115658087&userid=329114&signature=DbD51YugNYRnUSXpn9F0wA

I just want to make sure I'm not undercutting them, ignore the uncommon, its meant as a trade gift in addition to the other pets...
How many pets give or take from older years should I be tacking on?

[ChocolateGryphon]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=115689211&userid=361168&signature=cN64WhduDmfVcVuiHY7Cmw
Is this fair? Dog is from 2009 April!

[dwaekki]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=115689211&userid=361168&signature=cN64WhduDmfVcVuiHY7Cmw
Is this fair? Dog is from 2009 April!

your side =
(tier 8, line 3) AWD = .5ma (according to horror guide)

their side =
UR malk bun = 30-40 c$
2013 rare = ~20 c$

so this is unfair to you! they would need to add at least 80-100 c$ in pets, or around .3ma (i believe) in pets!

[Piruleta]

Hi! Would this be fair? I'm not sure how much the dog is worth but I feel like it might be a bit more than that.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=115702155&userid=537364&signature=spCsLSHHtRL688YtRFocHA

May you all have a good day!