The "Is this a fair trade" Thread

[Begs]

Can someone please help out? Who is under or over and by how much.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=68554446&userid=858203&signature=3Q1ttfpFBob_73YgtvsHQA

[pigeon -]

would this be a fair trade?

[Mavi]

would this be a fair trade?

It would be unfair to the pets, the 2011 pony would be enough for all three of them

[pigeon -]

Can someone please help out? Who is under or over and by how much.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=68554446&userid=858203&signature=3Q1ttfpFBob_73YgtvsHQA

you are overpaying, the store is worth a mid '10 rare, their side doesn't add up to that c:

[Smaug The Dragon]

What does the UR foal potentially trade for? How good is it's demand?
Would it be fair to trade a sorbet and non-balloon dog for one?

[kxynine]

Is this fair? ;w;
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 3ifTu_rJhA

Depends on how you value zodiac dogs. They can go for 1-2 09 rares, so, technically, this trade COULD be fair. I wouldn't accept, because I value them at two 09 rares, and the C$10 doesn't fill the space with the second rare, but it's up to you and your trade partner how you value them.

Thanks! As it is my zodiac sign, and as the dog was my first dreamie that i've got. Im not quiet sure if i'd accept it tho.
Any second opinions?

[unona]

What should be added to make this fair?
Thanks in advance~

[Mavi]

Is this fair? ;w;
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 3ifTu_rJhA

Depends on how you value zodiac dogs. They can go for 1-2 09 rares, so, technically, this trade COULD be fair. I wouldn't accept, because I value them at two 09 rares, and the C$10 doesn't fill the space with the second rare, but it's up to you and your trade partner how you value them.

Thanks! As it is my zodiac sign, and as the dog was my first dreamie that i've got. Im not quiet sure if i'd accept it tho.
Any second opinions?

By rarity it is an overpay, demand wise is really up to you and your trading partner, but if it is your first dream pet you don't have to trade it, it is solely up to you and whether you want your pet more or their pet more

[Smaug The Dragon]

What does the UR foal potentially trade for? How good is it's demand?
Would it be fair to trade a sorbet and non-balloon dog for one?

[huskypawz]

Fair?

Edit:

Heart PPS = Dark Wood + ??