Staff Litter Discussion Thread

[~Clockwork~]

The eye's of today's outcome resemble Pandle perfectly, so you don't need to confirm that one.
However, you haven't confirmed or denied a single pup, so it's time to put our thinking caps on.

The answer to your riddle was "My pup is simple." The troll message must be a way of throwing us off.
If your pup was simple, that means it would also tie into the lie of your two truths one lie game previously.
What pups that have grown already are relatively simple, and have edits? A somewhat vast minority.

Now, lets look at the items we were provided, starting with the butterfly. Doesn't that seem obvious?
It points straight at the caterpillar pup, as a caterpillar transforms into a butterfly through metamorphosis.
However, when we look at the wool-knit hat, that points towards the dogs who has "stitches" on them, right?
The teddy bear is throwing me off though- does that point to the dog being fluffy? Or, when you look at the
eyes of the teddy bear, doesn't it oddly look like the eyes of this dog?:


As of what I have inferred, that narrows it down to 3 pups:

Feel free to criticize me- I am by no no means a good detective, haha.
I just wish we had some more denials to work off of. hint hint nudge nudge

I would think the teddy bear would strengthen the idea of the plushie pup.

[Keilime]

-snip-

The eye's of today's outcome resemble Pandle perfectly, so you don't need to confirm that one.
However, you haven't confirmed or denied a single pup, so it's time to put our thinking caps on.

The answer to your riddle was "My pup is simple." The troll message must be a way of throwing us off.
If your pup was simple, that means it would also tie into the lie of your two truths one lie game previously.
What pups that have grown already are relatively simple, and have edits? A somewhat vast minority.

Now, lets look at the items we were provided, starting with the butterfly. Doesn't that seem obvious?
It points straight at the caterpillar pup, as a caterpillar transforms into a butterfly through metamorphosis.
However, when we look at the wool-knit hat, that points towards the dogs who has "stitches" on them, right?
The teddy bear is throwing me off though- does that point to the dog being fluffy? Or, when you look at the
eyes of the teddy bear, doesn't it oddly look like the eyes of this dog?:


As of what I have inferred, that narrows it down to 3 pups:

Feel free to criticize me- I am by no no means a good detective, haha.
I just wish we had some more denials to work off of. hint hint nudge nudge

Interesting analysis! I'll go ahead and confirm that this pup:



Is not mine

Darn, I had a suspicion it wasn't yours, but I had to try haha. It doesn't
fit your normal style. However, that must mean that the teddy bear points to fluffiness/innocence maybe?
Which puts the caterpillar pup into a new spotlight. However, you didn't deny the stitched up pup, so that
also leaves it in the question as well.

I would think the teddy bear would strengthen the idea of the plushie pup.

You are correct, actually- how did that fly over my head?
The butterfly seems like an obvious hint though- it might just be the stitch dog.

[Coraychi]

But how does a butterfly (one of Swift's missing items) tie into a plushie? That's the one thing that I'm not getting. o:

[AnewLeif]

Has anyone else thought the magical girl dog is Verdana's?
The items would match someone in an anime, the alchemy book, the googles, and the headgear/crown thing?
And the hints
"My staff dog, which has at least one lineart edit." -This dog has
"No, my puppy does not have purple eyes." - This pups eyes are closed
Does not have the regular straight tail - This is the only hint that doesn't match, could be a misdirection?

I don't think a mod would outright lie just to through us off. Be sneaky, or withhold part of the truth yeah, but lying completely is a bit much I think. I'm pretty positive that the anime pup is Vampiric's, personally.

Thant's true.
Why do you think it's theirs?

[reynard]

Lets try a different route here.
Same theory as Jack did, if you can find a pup and explain why my hints fit or don't fit, I will confirm or deny that pup.

However, you MUST explain all of my hints, all of my items, and why you think it's mine.

Good luck!

[Obius]

Ok so Atwood has said the ears were based on flopped ears and NOT that the ears were flopped from the get go. This in addition to the adults could also turn floppy eared even when the pup does not posess this trait. So all straight eared pups are fair game.

Next, Atwood claimed her pup had grown by now. I too had focused too heavily on the flop eared clue...

This leaves Atwoods current clues and my theory of being a fruit colored Superstar. And with that, I propose that....


Pet's name: Sauna
Adopt virtual pets at Chicken Smoothie!

This pup is Atwoods!!! She has a fruit treatment going on with green fruit mix to exfoliate the skin. The cucumbers or lemons also fit. The pup sure is taking great care of her face from the start. And she has not blossomed into a superstar yet. Hence the lyrics Still at the start!

Now the spa treatment deserves special attention. Its not cheap to do! Once I got quotes from a place that reached $270 for a basic all day spa treatment. Stars usually want to take care of themselves and treat themselves. A Spa Treatment is typically the way to go since it both nourishes the skin and comes bundled with a massage and pedicure treatment (depending on plan and place). Stars (my emphasis for all of Atwoods movie and music references) want to look their best after all. And a spa is the perfect pampered experience! All the fruit clues merely suggest colors used or (in this case) a star treatment! So my theory is that the pup above is in fact Atwoods!

I shall rest on my theory unless other evidence suggests otherwise.

**** Reposting with a reason ****

Guys! Since Atwood's floppy eared pup was just a reference to the base used in the final form, and that the pup had grown BEFORE ROLLOVER, do you guys think all the clues out there suggest this pup is Atwoods?

[Coraychi]

Has anyone else thought the magical girl dog is Verdana's?
The items would match someone in an anime, the alchemy book, the googles, and the headgear/crown thing?
And the hints
"My staff dog, which has at least one lineart edit." -This dog has
"No, my puppy does not have purple eyes." - This pups eyes are closed
Does not have the regular straight tail - This is the only hint that doesn't match, could be a misdirection?

I don't think a mod would outright lie just to through us off. Be sneaky, or withhold part of the truth yeah, but lying completely is a bit much I think. :/ I'm pretty positive that the anime pup is Vampiric's, personally.

Thant's true.
Why do you think it's theirs?

Well, Vamp doesn't have any clues out, but I've been on this site for a really long time and have seen a lot of her art and pets. I recognize her style pretty quick now, and the anime pup screams Vampiric to me. The style of the lines looks just likes some of her previous pets. Plus she often does hair and clothes for her staff pets. o:

[Aliria]

Has anyone else thought the magical girl dog is Verdana's?
The items would match someone in an anime, the alchemy book, the googles, and the headgear/crown thing?
And the hints
"My staff dog, which has at least one lineart edit." -This dog has
"No, my puppy does not have purple eyes." - This pups eyes are closed
Does not have the regular straight tail - This is the only hint that doesn't match, could be a misdirection?

I don't think a mod would outright lie just to through us off. Be sneaky, or withhold part of the truth yeah, but lying completely is a bit much I think. I'm pretty positive that the anime pup is Vampiric's, personally.

Thant's true.
Why do you think it's theirs?

I agree that it looks like Vampiric's. If you look at her staff pups from 2015 and 2013, the style is noticeably very similar.

[Coraychi]

Heck, I'm just gonna share this now, but these are my biggest theories at the moment? I've been keeping a list, so I might as well post it~ ovo I haven't made sure all the hints match with these, they're just what I think the pups LOOK like. They're purely based on art-style similarities~

Sketchy pup - Solarizing
Anime pup - Vampiric
Comet pup - Bernouli
Fawn pup - Pluma or Solloby
Owl pup - Sakiyoko

[AnewLeif]

-snip-

I agree that it looks like Vampiric's. If you look at her staff pups from 2015 and 2013, the style is noticeably very similar.

Yeah, now that I go and look back it does look pretty similar!