The "Is this a fair trade" Thread

[luc]

Awwhh, sorry for spamming this thread but I just finished by cerb auction and I want to make the most well-informed decision. So I was wondering if I could get opinions on the bids? Thank you so much!

Bid 1
Bid 2
Bid 3
Bid 4

Absolutely bid 2 I Mean I saw sunback go for sunjewel few times then there Is coontail = 2 nons And other Pets which gives you another non value

Agreed.

Thanks! Could I get just one more opnion? And does this bid impact it in anyway?

[pigeon -]

this one too?
thanks!

The bmd could be valued around a sorbet and so can the bengal. So I’d say it would be a fair swap for either of your pets but as it is right now, it’s unfair to you. (Answer based demand wise)

thank you, can i get another opinion too? c:

[shisho]

this one too?
thanks!

The bmd could be valued around a sorbet and so can the bengal. So I’d say it would be a fair swap for either of your pets but as it is right now, it’s unfair to you. (Answer based demand wise)

thank you, can i get another opinion too? c:

well, the bmd goes for around a balloon dog and the ur bengal tends to go for a sorbet, so the ur bengal itself would be fair.

[kxynine]

Is this fair? ;w;
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 3ifTu_rJhA

[huskypawz]

Is this fair? ;w;
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 3ifTu_rJhA

Depends on how you value zodiac dogs. They can go for 1-2 09 rares, so, technically, this trade COULD be fair. I wouldn't accept, because I value them at two 09 rares, and the C$10 doesn't fill the space with the second rare, but it's up to you and your trade partner how you value them.

Is this fair rarity and demand wise? :3

So if the Angel Advent is worth ~280 C$ and each store pet is 20 C$, that would be 14 store pets. You have like 2.5x that. I would say you are way overpaying. Get a second opinion.

please do not compare pets to C$ in a trade where C$ isn't involved.
the angel advent is worth 49-ish '09 rares, tofoo's side is worth 34 '09 rares so unfair to the angel advent.

I agree.

[kaiserbakura]

Is this trade i suggested fair? I really want those dragons

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=68557569&userid=901965&signature=Qs6w-p6EYRDJmPxHoVxtZg

[pigeon -]

Is this trade i suggested fair? I really want those dragons

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=68557569&userid=901965&signature=Qs6w-p6EYRDJmPxHoVxtZg

unfair to you, one of your horses would have been fair for the two
uncommon dragons, so the other '14 uncommon is overpay :*

[kxynine]

Is this fair? ;w;
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 3ifTu_rJhA

Depends on how you value zodiac dogs. They can go for 1-2 09 rares, so, technically, this trade COULD be fair. I wouldn't accept, because I value them at two 09 rares, and the C$10 doesn't fill the space with the second rare, but it's up to you and your trade partner how you value them.

Thanks! As it is my zodiac sign, and as the dog was my first dreamie that i've got. Im not quiet sure if i'd accept it tho.
Any second opinions?

[huskypawz]

Is this trade i suggested fair? I really want those dragons

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=68557569&userid=901965&signature=Qs6w-p6EYRDJmPxHoVxtZg

Using the 2:1 rule for trading up/down years, the two 2015 dragons would be fair for one of the horses, but the other dragon doesn't cover the second horse. It'd be unfair to you, but it also could depends on value. You may value horses less, therefore will undertrade them. It's up to you and your trade partner, but personally, I wouldn't accept.

[kaiserbakura]

Thanks to both of you. Sadly the trade was cancelled so i guess it doesnt matter in the end