The "Is this a fair Trade?" thread.

[weby099]

okay, so I have an Auction for the Yellow Sorbet and someone wants to know which one is the best. Im horrible at these things, so Im turning to you guys xD

Offers - (wishlist offers are in red and dreamlist offers are in yellow.)

Emma Saige - Blue Balloon (BlueBalloon - Kinda In between Wish+DreamList)
Silverkit - 3 Rare Rats, 2 '08 Advents, PPS Ornament (2 '08 Advents, PPS Ornament Advent, 3 Rare Rats, Everything Except Rats on DreamList/Wishlist)
nekoasato - 2 Advents and DrinkMe+EatMe Dogs (All on Wishlist)
kittenpompom123 - (I think it's the best, but i dunno) All pets from THIS group + 27C$.

?

[qittenpie]

Pet's name:

for a green Malk Dragon and A Halloween Pumpkin Butterwolf?

OR

What pet from the Halloween event would make it fair? (I want to keep the green dragon in there. :3 )

~/\~

Oh, and I forgot to put this in my post (X3)

A Bridle, All purpose Saddle (the free items) ; and a green bandana and a black spiked collar from the store for

A Pumpkin Butterwolf and A dark Malk owl?

[Eva]

okay, so I have an Auction for the Yellow Sorbet and someone wants to know which one is the best. Im horrible at these things, so Im turning to you guys xD

Offers - (wishlist offers are in red and dreamlist offers are in yellow.)

Emma Saige - Blue Balloon (BlueBalloon - Kinda In between Wish+DreamList)
Silverkit - 3 Rare Rats, 2 '08 Advents, PPS Ornament (2 '08 Advents, PPS Ornament Advent, 3 Rare Rats, Everything Except Rats on DreamList/Wishlist)
nekoasato - 2 Advents and DrinkMe+EatMe Dogs (All on Wishlist)
kittenpompom123 - (I think it's the best, but i dunno) All pets from THIS group + 27C$.

?

I would say the one that offers most of your wishlist pets... I would choose that one because it would complete my collection faster, I'm saying this as if it were my desition :]

Haha ... I have a drink me dog + eat me dog + Skele Bunny and a couple other things I would give to you :]

[ocelotboye]

Ohhh...godss...

THEIR SIDE:
Clear eyed galaxy!!

MY SIDE:
Red X PPS
08 Army Dog
08 Nick Birthday Dog
Bone PPS
Three December08 doggies, One uncommon.
Desert PPS
Three Lions
Angel PPS
Two non grown PPS, Hearts bobtail and Red panda

Is this a fair trade?

[Kari Lion]

Quick feedback please

This person apparently "accidentally" traded some pets to me, and now they want them back, so they're offering me other pets in return.

their side:
Line Tribal
bicolored eyes green swirl dog

my side:
still newborn card lion
evil shima non PPS
Panda non PPS
Okapi non PPS

I edited it back taking out the lion, but they edited it back in. I really want the lion... what do you guys think?

[KyoshiYan]

I would take the tribal then again I am biased. XD

[acciobadger]

o.o
I'd accept.

[Coalchaser]

I'd accept, too. The lions are going to be rereleased at least once, so you'll either get the lion you want or you can use one of the ones you get to trade for it.

[Kari Lion]

All right, thanks guys. I was pretty sure I should accept it, but people are getting crazy things for advents. Interestingly, they sent that as a suggestion so I couldn't actually accept. I have to wait now for them to accept the offer they sent to me... yeah.

[loyalwolf06]

Me:

Them: today's Ornament Newborn

Fair or not?

Can I get a second opinion on this?