The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Daxx]

I know this is unfair to my jokerbun , but by how much?? Any help is appreciated, thank y'all! Been asking for a few pages, so id love some input!

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97515350&userid=774759&signature=72hvG7usJCuMGYZRlLlf2Q

[*Nevi Nova*]

is this trade fair at all? its a very large trade Boop includes some dec 18 pets, and a large amount of items

[Nicnova]

I’ve never been good with item rarities, and I only just recently came back, but this is overpay isn’t it? I just wanted to double check.

[Miang]

Is this trade fair? I am not sure if the guinea pig is worth anything more than 2 rares? the lion is originally from 2009

[~Graceful Fox~]

May I have some thoughts on this bid^^ Thank you in advance

[Kate,]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97522335&userid=830519&signature=1mbVfVIqh3WqwIPyWvXaYA

Is this worth it? (Raven valued at 5nons)

[pochita]

Hiya! trades/viewtrade.php?id=97514943&userid=901300&signature=N3UbFyDGZp8T7b3rB7Tu7A

Pleasesgstehd

[lextopia]

hi there,
is this fair demand wise?
thank you!

[Rocki]

Hiya! trades/viewtrade.php?id=97514943&userid=901300&signature=N3UbFyDGZp8T7b3rB7Tu7A

Pleasesgstehd

The drink me is ~6n and the eat me ~5, and the galaxy cat being 1.5 or something. All 3 of them with pretty good demand
That would be 12.5n while the skelebun can go for 10-15, usually on the higher end. If you're happy with that trade it's not that bad to take, but it's not the highest you can get. Not many people offer for the skelebun in general since it's so valuable- just my personal opinion

[Rocki]

hi there,
is this fair demand wise?
thank you!

I think they're over as I see an '09 VR as being able to get 4 '10 R, but malk pets tend to have higher demand/go for more so they won't be over by that much. It depends whether or not you guys are happy with the trade and value the pets that high but personally I would've taken it even if they removed one of their 3 random rares