The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[sunka]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=115674638&userid=123042&signature=JzWXRNdTY5E8D6HtFJqbew

^ thoughts please? i believe it is overpay, but not sure how the demand of the flamingo in comparison to my side.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=115678254&userid=123042&signature=fzfm5fI7I1607caylBN41Q
thoughts on this as well please

[angst]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=115674638&userid=123042&signature=JzWXRNdTY5E8D6HtFJqbew

^ thoughts please? i believe it is overpay, but not sure how the demand of the flamingo in comparison to my side.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=115678254&userid=123042&signature=fzfm5fI7I1607caylBN41Q
thoughts on this as well please

The first one is a better trade value wise but the flamingo can be very hard to trade off! If you really want the flamingo it's a good trade but it has really poor demand.

The second one I'm not sure about - personally I'm not good with CS! If you don't want the CS though, you could ask them to do their 2 2011 store pets + a 1MA store pet and it'd be fair for one of your androids as both sides would be 5MA. Get a real opinion on this one though!

[storm coming.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=115636728&userid=1041433&signature=IiOZd7uZCN8HW93n_5hpVg

Correct link lol

your side:
hollyfox - 2-3 ma

their side:
BMD bun - 2 ma
hollypaw - 0.5 ma
= 2.5 ma

fair trade rarity-wise, just depends what side you prefer. I will note that demand-wise the hollyfox dog has great demand and bunnies are usually harder to trade off.

[mushroomish]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=115658755&userid=978329&signature=-kAV7MR7-HDRMbsF6C2EEA

Can I have some help please? (not sure whymy links keep not working as I am copying them from the right place, hopefully this time!!)

[Animooser]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=115658087&userid=329114&signature=DbD51YugNYRnUSXpn9F0wA

I just want to make sure I'm not undercutting them, ignore the uncommon, its meant as a trade gift in addition to the other pets...

[udo#]

need help with thiss trade

[GhostPants]

How does this look :)?
@ghostpantz

[FairSky]

Hi there! ♡

It's been over a decade since I've last been on this site properly. A lot has changed and I no longer have a good sense for how values work. 😅

Could I therefore maybe get some opinions on this trade? The other person seems lovely, I just don't really have the ability to evaluate things properly.

Trade:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=115638032&userid=28639&signature=OiX3NGdBVBCbJX__kK3oQQ

Thank you in advance! ♡

[dwaekki]

Hi there! ♡

It's been over a decade since I've last been on this site properly. A lot has changed and I no longer have a good sense for how values work. 😅

Could I therefore maybe get some opinions on this trade? The other person seems lovely, I just don't really have the ability to evaluate things properly.

Trade:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=115638032&userid=28639&signature=OiX3NGdBVBCbJX__kK3oQQ

Thank you in advance! ♡

your side:
orange cerb = 10 NONs
(ranges from 8-10, but are rarely traded)

your total: 10 NONs (or 100 MA)

their side:
(line 7, tier 1) UR phoenix = 1.5 NON
(line 7, tier 1) UR holly dog = 1.5 NON
(line 7, tier 1) UR galaxy cat = 1.5 NON
(line 12, tier 1) UR grapes = .5 NON
(line 4, tier 3) red x pps = 4 MA
(line 2, tier 5) BMD = .75 NON
(line 2, tier 3) pink sorbet = .75 NON
blue android = .5 NON
6000 c$ = 3 NON

their total value: 10.4 NONs (or 104 MA)

so, this is fair (technically a small overpay but yk.. orange cerb is really difficult to get!) to you! i cannot give you insight on demand or any recommendations as ive never traded using any of these pets before, but i do know that it is very hard to get both the orange and red cerb! i will also warn that it is difficult to trade up for good pets using c$. but this trade is up to you!

please get a second opinion though, as i got most of the stuff from horrors guide! i just know that its fair, i wouldn't know demand of any of their side <3

[Veneti]

Hi there! ♡

It's been over a decade since I've last been on this site properly. A lot has changed and I no longer have a good sense for how values work. 😅

Could I therefore maybe get some opinions on this trade? The other person seems lovely, I just don't really have the ability to evaluate things properly.

Trade:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=115638032&userid=28639&signature=OiX3NGdBVBCbJX__kK3oQQ

Thank you in advance! ♡

Allot of their pets are low demand, If you want to trade down I suggest getting pets that will be easier to trade off in the long run, unless you're specifically looking for those pets. As for the c$, it's hard to buy List pets for c$ because not many people sell them, so I would ask for pets to fill in that space instead.

Orange Cerb has been trading for 12N consistently from the Successful Trade Thread, not 10N