The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[sunfloweer]

i need some help on these trades

would this be a good idea to accept in the long run?

and

would this be fair?

[Space Avian]

i need some help on these trades

would this be a good idea to accept in the long run?

and

would this be fair?

The banana is worth 1-1.5 nons, but the demand isn't that great
Depending on how you value the banana this may be fair

The strawberry goes for 1-1.5 nons, while the nonballoon is 0.5 nons for a total of 1.5-2 nons

The smore goes from 1-2 nons currently, so depending on how you value the pets it may be fair
Personally I wouldn't accept, because although demand for the smore is high right now, it will probably settle down once it gets assigned a rarity

[executable]

i need some help on these trades

would this be a good idea to accept in the long run?

and

would this be fair?

On the first trade, according to the condensed rares list, a banana is worth a sunjewel. On the other hand, a banana goes for exactly a non according to the Demand List.

So... it'd be a basic swap, if I'm reading the demand list versus the rares list correctly. If you can get someone to trade you a non for banana, there is no reason to keep the banana. (although I have no trade links, so this entire speculation is pure heresay).

[sunfloweer]

i need some help on these trades

would this be a good idea to accept in the long run?

and

would this be fair?

On the first trade, according to the condensed rares list, a banana is worth a sunjewel. On the other hand, a banana goes for exactly a non according to the Demand List.

So... it'd be a basic swap, if I'm reading the demand list versus the rares list correctly. If you can get someone to trade you a non for banana, there is no reason to keep the banana. (although I have no trade links, so this entire speculation is pure heresay).

what are your thoughts on the 2nd trade?

[sunfloweer]

i need some help on these trades

would this be a good idea to accept in the long run?

and

would this be fair?

The banana is worth 1-1.5 nons, but the demand isn't that great
Depending on how you value the banana this may be fair

The strawberry goes for 1-1.5 nons, while the nonballoon is 0.5 nons for a total of 1.5-2 nons

The smore goes from 1-2 nons currently, so depending on how you value the pets it may be fair
Personally I wouldn't accept, because although demand for the smore is high right now, it will probably settle down once it gets assigned a rarity

ahh okay tysm!

[P0procks]

I’m kinda lost on this one, would it be fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91878631&userid=788183&signature=avFSMPmob5gEmPtO0kMdNA

Or is this one better?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91879080&userid=788183&signature=KwpHq-UfAyq-OGM81YG9Tw

[Blue_Aussie]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91879020&userid=768234&signature=8_vFX9Pk9ycULGzcBHVYtA

[sunfloweer]

i need an opinion on this trade ^^

ty in advance

[yellowjjacket]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91867977&userid=860974&signature=yAt_eBcJU7Wi3wroTR8YhQ
Help?

Anyone?

page 483


i traded them and we both need to know if this is fair thank you

[GhostPants]

this? xxx