The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[weld]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92069708&userid=815492&signature=TDHzJGsageZBSrz-uh1W9g

does this look fair??

[Nerel]

Hello! I believe this would be unfair, right?

your tess horse was an extended release, so it is worth 2 09 rares or 3-month rule (scroll down til you see the horse images).

the items on your side are all worth a common/uncommon from release date:
- gold token* - archive/2013/Easter/Items/
- pink & purple token - archive/2014/Easter/Items/
- scaredy cat cookie* & ghostmallow* - archive/2014/Halloween/Items/?pageStart=10
- dyed egg, easter egg gift - archive/2015/Easter/Items/
- easter egg - archive/2017/Easter/Items/
- candy apple* - archive/2017/Halloween/Items/?pageStart=10
- easter egg - archive/2018/Easter/Items/
- easter egg - archive/2019/Easter/Items/
the ones with * next to them are more likely to be an uncommon imo, and the rest are worth a common or less from release date (due to being free releases/ not used as tokens).
== roughly 2 2013 uc + 2013 c + 2014 c + 2017 c & uc + 1 2018 c + 1 2019 vc
note: seeing as a 2010 common == 4 2013 uc, your items don't even match the extra pets on their side.

considering that the two 09 dogs are a fair swap for your tess horse, the '10 uncommons & '10 rare are actually overpay for your items. unfair to the top.

Thank you for the very detailed explanation!

[caffeinate]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92072649&userid=1003859&signature=0KfirmjseKz3QCioEn8AHg

?

[Sori]

Is this fair? Currently the leading bid of my auction, just wanted to double check before it ends in a few days!

[-Explorer-]

Is this fair? Currently the leading bid of my auction, just wanted to double check before it ends in a few days!

Unfair to you, EM+DM go for about 12 nons together while their side is only equivalent to about 9 nons

BA(1) + GL (2,5) + Bengal(1,5) + Moonswirl(2,5) + Lolita (1,5) = 9

[Horsesrule5000]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92069708&userid=815492&signature=TDHzJGsageZBSrz-uh1W9g

does this look fair??

This seems pretty fair. The kitsune is not a list pet like your bun, but it has been going for list pets recently.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92072649&userid=1003859&signature=0KfirmjseKz3QCioEn8AHg

?

Unfair to them, the dalmation dog alone is worth 40c$.

[heaven.]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92070102&userid=395590&signature=F0x09X4M86AVV5eFTKBPzQ

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92059093&userid=395590&signature=4LyRrHR5m-10OHZ6ePj8CQ

either of these fair ??

[tens]

Does anyone have input for this? Thank you ^^

[caffeinate]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92072649&userid=1003859&signature=0KfirmjseKz3QCioEn8AHg

?

Unfair to them, the dalmation dog alone is worth 40c$.[/quote]

Thanks!

[Tapedeck]

Alright boys, back again

Would this + Nick Unicorn + Pink Heart be getting close to the 1-3 Non gap between the Sun Jewel and Ur Tiger Dog ? How many rares am I lacking ?

(My Sunpup has officially reached 30 days and isn’t a non-jewel so I think it’s safe to assume)

If you mean another sunjewel then 100% you’d close the gap with just the two of those. If you mean the group + a unickorn and a tier 7, I think it’d equal ~4.5 nons in total? Give it a second opinion though my math probably sucks

Thank you for the input !! 💕 It’s the whole group plus the two extra pets. If I’m coming up on 4.5 nons that would be a miracle since I’m trying to get to 2 nons + Sunjewel for my trade partner

So valuing the Tiger Dog at 5 nons, may I have another opinion ?