The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Nerel]

Hello! I believe this would be unfair, right?

[-Explorer-]

I have these that I would love help with if anyone has a second ❤️
1
2
3 Here they said ‘ Alternatively the Balloon and Sorb can be taken out for the Banana’
4 They aren’t asking for all, they put ‘I added a green sorbet for a straight swap or the toxic + ma’s for a trade down’

Any advice would be great!! I’m hopeless! Thankyou ❤️

1st trade im clueless of, not good with items

2nd trade is overpay on their side by about 3 09 rares

3rd trade is about fair, bee goes for 2.5 - 3 nons and that is what you have on your side

4th trade is unfair to you, UR Dog only goes for a sorb

[mae]

Is this fair?<3


-rain

[ahirked]

I have these that I would love help with if anyone has a second ❤️
1
2
3 Here they said ‘ Alternatively the Balloon and Sorb can be taken out for the Banana’
4 They aren’t asking for all, they put ‘I added a green sorbet for a straight swap or the toxic + ma’s for a trade down’

1st trade im clueless of, not good with items

2nd trade is overpay on their side by about 3 09 rares

3rd trade is about fair, bee goes for 2.5 - 3 nons and that is what you have on your side

4th trade is unfair to you, UR Dog only goes for a sorb

for the first (item) trade, your items are worth a 2011 uncommon each at least, so what they're offering isn't fair at all. their side adds up to a 2015 uncommon and a couple of 2019/2020 uncommons at most.

[Berenice]

Is this fair?
Thanks!

[skypoppy]

I'd love some advice on this, thanks!

[ahirked]

Hello! I believe this would be unfair, right?

your tess horse was an extended release, so it is worth 2 09 rares or 3-month rule (scroll down til you see the horse images).

the items on your side are all worth a common/uncommon from release date:
- gold token* - archive/2013/Easter/Items/
- pink & purple token - archive/2014/Easter/Items/
- scaredy cat cookie* & ghostmallow* - archive/2014/Halloween/Items/?pageStart=10
- dyed egg, easter egg gift - archive/2015/Easter/Items/
- easter egg - archive/2017/Easter/Items/
- candy apple* - archive/2017/Halloween/Items/?pageStart=10
- easter egg - archive/2018/Easter/Items/
- easter egg - archive/2019/Easter/Items/
the ones with * next to them are more likely to be an uncommon imo, and the rest are worth a common or less from release date (due to being free releases/ not used as tokens).
== roughly 2 2013 uc + 2013 c + 2014 c + 2017 c & uc + 1 2018 c + 1 2019 vc
note: seeing as a 2010 common == 4 2013 uc, your items don't even match the extra pets on their side.

considering that the two 09 dogs are a fair swap for your tess horse, the '10 uncommons & '10 rare are actually overpay for your items. unfair to the top.

[-Explorer-]

Is this fair?
Thanks!

Overpay on the top, that store pet goes for a MA while your horse goes for less

I'd love some advice on this, thanks!

About a fair swap, both go for 1,5 nons but I usually see the marionette get more

[tonio]

Ur Galaxy cat for 2 pineapples? Thoughts?

[pochita]

Ur Galaxy cat for 2 pineapples? Thoughts?

Ur galaxy cat is 1-1.5 nons while each pineapple is a good non
It’d be overpay on the pineapple side but the demand is worse so it’s up to you if the overpay makes up for it