The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[DelightfulMelon]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... T7tt98HgIg

would these pets equal a low list? I feel like its too much to equal a low list

[horchata]

what would need to be added to this trade? tysm!

[LyricalChaos]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 5E29NpzNgQ

Any help?? Thanks!

[z i m]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66172362&userid=444055&signature=dLYUCF0rSgM7T7tt98HgIg

would these pets equal a low list? I feel like its too much to equal a low list

low list as in main, september, or advent? two of those pets are advent lists (i'm sure you're aware), so i think those all might add up to a low-mid september?
please get a second opinion as i'm still learning september list trades and values.

[Madziu]

Trying to end an auction, which bid is the best out of the three?
One
Two
Three

Thanks for the help!

[Corey Taylor]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66176340&userid=781126&signature=6fjBAsKL5_MEj8GBOS29UA

What should they add if it isnt fair?

Thank you for the other responses <3

[lady gaga]

could i have some opinions on these trades? Demand wise, please.

[Animall]

Exactly how unfair is this to me? We both realize the pineapple has low demand, so I'm trying to make sure the rarity and demand on their side is decent enough to be acceptable for the rarity of the pineapple. What should be added/removed? I'm not sure how much the pineapple goes for in regards to its demand! ^^

Overall: What does the pineapple tend to go for in regards to its demand? Does their offer line up with said demand value? Could I get more?

x x x

[DelightfulMelon]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66172362&userid=444055&signature=dLYUCF0rSgM7T7tt98HgIg

would these pets equal a low list? I feel like its too much to equal a low list

low list as in main, september, or advent? two of those pets are advent lists (i'm sure you're aware), so i think those all might add up to a low-mid september?
please get a second opinion as i'm still learning september list trades and values.

I meant a low main <3

[Eagle's Eye]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66172362&userid=444055&signature=dLYUCF0rSgM7T7tt98HgIg

would these pets equal a low list? I feel like its too much to equal a low list

low list as in main, september, or advent? two of those pets are advent lists (i'm sure you're aware), so i think those all might add up to a low-mid september?
please get a second opinion as i'm still learning september list trades and values.

The flop blood dog is advent tier 5 and worth 6-7 '09 rares each. The '13 store pets are worth a mid '09 rare each; your side is worth 16-18 2009 rares. Your pets are worth roughly a target dog tier, which is worth 2 mid advents plus 2 '09 rares // 14-18 '09 rares. The lowest main list is worth 10 mid advents, so you'd have to add a lot more.