Lock please <3

[Scripted]

Am I correct in thinking that this is unfair to me? What could be added?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... dEHIXRSPoQ

Hi again. Seems like I'm always running into you lately.

As for the trade, I actually think it's pretty fair. The Horse is a few months older, but I see alot more people looking for the Butterfly Wolf than I do the horse.

As for the Uncommons, they're both rather easy to get, so it really comes down to which one you like more.

Edit: Is this fair for my Line Tribal?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... eUAxjK1p4Q
Grinner & the rat are worth Septembers, although rats are notoriously hard to get fair trades for. I love the bunny though.
I have a horrible feeling I had the Line Tribal lined up for another trade O.o; Gah. Not enough time to deal with all these trades.

At the worst, it's fair for the Line tribal. The Light Pawprint Rat is worth a September '08 rare, as are the bunny and the Grinner.

So it's technically 3 September '08 rares for 1 August VR. It's your call really.

please help! http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ZDTc6x5mmQ

Unfair to the bunny. The more sought after '09 bunnies(like that one) tend to go for September '08 rares.

[Solloby]

Timezones maybe? ^.^
Hmm, interesting. It's hard to tell how rare a 'rare' is.

My trades have all piled up lol. This BFW is a VDay one, do you think I could ask for more 09 uncommons for it? If so, how many? I don't know if the BFW is as highly wanted as the other VDay pets.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Pcdd9gce5A

[Scripted]

Timezones maybe? ^.^
Hmm, interesting. It's hard to tell how rare a 'rare' is.

My trades have all piled up lol. This BFW is a VDay one, do you think I could ask for more 09 uncommons for it? If so, how many? I don't know if the BFW is as highly wanted as the other VDay pets.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Pcdd9gce5A

Possibly. Either way, I hope I'm being useful.

As far as that trade, you could easily get a few more.

The BW is an early '09 Rare and an event pet. I say try for 5 Uncommons or so, unless you want dogs from Jan.'09-June '09. Then I would say 3-4 Uncommon Dogs.

[Solloby]

You're being very helpful, thank you

I am still new to all of this. I also do not know much about trades. So I am going to start asking.

Is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=7389154&userid=173828&signature=v5DMrSx8MaABU-Mwwvwi8g

To be honest, I wouldn't accept that unless you really like all pets on their side. People seem to be overvaluing these PPS pups so you might want to consider keeping them for a bit. I got a nice 2010 uncommon each for two of mine, so it's not hard to do better.

Ally202: Use the Rares List Guide, it's in the same forum as this thread and usually on the first or second page.

[.muse.]

Side A: Gearback Tribal

Side B: Non Balloon, Angel Advent, Rose PPS, Red X PPS, Orange Grinner, Scarf PPS, Ornament EPPS.

Which side needs to add more? And about how much more?

[Scripted]

Side A: Gearback Tribal

Side B: Non Balloon, Angel Advent, Rose PPS, Red X PPS, Orange Grinner, Scarf PPS, Ornament EPPS.

Which side needs to add more? And about how much more?

I would say that's a bit unfair to the X PPS side.

The gap between the Nonballoon and the Gearback isn't that big. The Angel Advent is worth a September '08 Rare, possibly VR., Then the Grinner is worth a September Rare.. The Scarf PPS is one of the best '08 Advents, meaning it's probably worth about a September '08 VR.

Then you have the Rose PPS and X PPS. Basically the 2 best September '08 VR's.

In my opinion, the Tribal side should add a good September VR, like a Blue Rose or even a Dark Leopard.

[.muse.]

Side A: Gearback Tribal

Side B: Non Balloon, Angel Advent, Rose PPS, Red X PPS, Orange Grinner, Scarf PPS, Ornament EPPS.

Which side needs to add more? And about how much more?

I would say that's a bit unfair to the X PPS side.

The gap between the Nonballoon and the Gearback isn't that big. The Angel Advent is worth a September '08 Rare, possibly VR., Then the Grinner is worth a September Rare.. The Scarf PPS is one of the best '08 Advents, meaning it's probably worth about a September '08 VR.

Then you have the Rose PPS and X PPS. Basically the 2 best September '08 VR's.

In my opinion, the Tribal side should add a good September VR, like a Blue Rose or even a Dark Leopard.

Would taking off the Rose PPS make it fair? Cause if anything that's my least favorite of the PPS on that side.

Also any second opinions? Since this post did get posted on at least like 5 pages before it got a reply.

[Solloby]

Are either of these good? The second sent is as a suggestion so I'm not sure what they want me to do.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 9fFmhvnZiA
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 5jiFe29BSQ

MuseFX: I feel it's unfair to Side B but I don't know by how much.

[Scripted]

Side A: Gearback Tribal

Side B: Non Balloon, Angel Advent, Rose PPS, Red X PPS, Orange Grinner, Scarf PPS, Ornament EPPS.

Which side needs to add more? And about how much more?

I would say that's a bit unfair to the X PPS side.

The gap between the Nonballoon and the Gearback isn't that big. The Angel Advent is worth a September '08 Rare, possibly VR., Then the Grinner is worth a September Rare.. The Scarf PPS is one of the best '08 Advents, meaning it's probably worth about a September '08 VR.

Then you have the Rose PPS and X PPS. Basically the 2 best September '08 VR's.

In my opinion, the Tribal side should add a good September VR, like a Blue Rose or even a Dark Leopard.

Would taking off the Rose PPS make it fair? Cause if anything that's my least favorite of the PPS on that side.

Also any second opinions? Since this post did get posted on at least like 5 pages before it got a reply.

Well, the Rose PPS is worth more than either the Blue Rose or Dark Leopard, so it would probably become a touch of an overoffer by the Tribal. But yes, it would basically be fair if you took off the Rose PPS.

Are either of these good? The second sent is as a suggestion so I'm not sure what they want me to do.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 9fFmhvnZiA
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 5jiFe29BSQ

First trade is unfair to the PeaPS. They both went rare within the last 2 months, but there seems to be more demand for the PeaPS. People really weren't looking for the Lava PPS until it went rare.

Second trade is unfair to you. Like I was saying, the PeaPS is really popular. I have seen almost no demand for the horse, except for the few people trying to complete collections.(Like Me...240 pets to go! )

[NocturnalPanda]

is this fair for blue tox? thanks
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... F44NoMUowA