The "Is This a Fair Trade" Thread

[Delta Dawn]

is this fair?? Not to sure so I don't wanna accept it yet d:

Its fair because both from the same tier but in demand wise i would say the pup as a little more demand because a lot of people like pps pets and want the pps one more then the full grown,and also you see the full grown one much more then you see your pps pup.

Okay, thanks ^-^

[Skull.Vincent]

Alright guys, so I know some list pets have terrible demand and some don't. So I just got this trade and I'm not sure if the Red X PPS is a hard one to trade away, like the pink patchy or the flop eared pink september, or if it has nice demand around the Raven Dog/Lolita. And if it's not too extreme on both ends, which would it be closer to?

I don't think he has /horrible/ demand but you have a lot of high demand pets on your end there. I'd get a second opinion though because I'm just coming back and his demand could have changed.

Second opinion? :]

[hainu]

Extremely unfair for you.
A couple of commons from '15 aren't worth a rare from '10.

alright, good to know! thanks.

I will double that, they would have to add more commons, but that's if you wish to trade down

alright, i edited it and sent it back, is this fair though? i'm trying for it to hopefully be fair for both of us but as stated. i don't trade here often so i've lost some sense on trades like these

[Delta Dawn]

How could this be made fair if it isn't already?

Also this one?

[Littlepengu]

Is this fair? Thank you
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... GDpD-p-YEQ

+ this one http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... gNOEGV384w

[diana,]

How could this be made fair if it isn't already?

Also this one?

1. Horribly unfair to you - your Grinner is on the sept. list and flop blood dog a 4th tier advent. Their snowflake scarf dog is a 1st tier advent.
2. Your desert orange swirl pup and flop blood dog are on the advent list [6th and 4th tiers] - the Cheshire Cat has good demand, but never have I seen it go for more than a 2-3 tier advent [in '09 rares also].

[~Arerona~]

Is this fair? Thanks in advance

[Delta Dawn]

How could this be made fair if it isn't already?

Also this one?

1. Horribly unfair to you - your Grinner is on the sept. list and flop blood dog a 4th tier advent. Their snowflake scarf dog is a 1st tier advent.
2. Your desert orange swirl pup and flop blood dog are on the advent list [6th and 4th tiers] - the Cheshire Cat has good demand, but never have I seen it go for more than a 2-3 tier advent [in '09 rares also].

What I thought d: Just wanted to make sure as I haven't played for a while

[Miss Amour]

this fair thank you ;W;
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... O248FooK0g
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... tNobctkmxw
another trade
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 9ZZBgFSYVg

[DepressedAnonymous]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... iJWCOxMHsg
What is needed to be added?