The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Mnemosyne]

how does this look? i'm not good at judging pet-item trades ;w;

[Kittytalia]

how does this look? i'm not good at judging pet-item trades ;w;

I wouldn't. The pocky goes for a lot more.

"They are worth a rare or very rare pet from October or November 2008, or something of similar value."
I've seen trades involving advents for them or $200 C$ c:

(information from the cs items guide)

I really want the pets on their side. Is this fair to them? Do I need to add?

total=358 items, with some diy candies on my side

(still need help! c: )

[maleficent.]

fair? I know the grinner and the Tess horse aren’t that good in demand, but I also know that the rat isn’t either. If unfair, what is it that would need to be added to make it a bit more fair? Thank you

[Gabyslá]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83920396&userid=938569&signature=wU9aJnDudXetTBLHEQoG9g
Would you take this considering the Joker demand?

[Kittytalia]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83920396&userid=938569&signature=wU9aJnDudXetTBLHEQoG9g
Would you take this considering the Joker demand?

I would call it a fair trade, as both the Joker and Dogtag can go for 1.5 nons.

[greenbunny1998]

Is this trade fair for my card dogs?

Thank you.

They are offering 3 09 rares worth + some uncommons and newer rares not mentioned because they don’t add up to much
Both of your dogs are worth 2 ‘09 rares and 1 ‘10 rare each as they are from Nov 2008. They need to add about 2 ‘09 rares to be fair rarity wise.

Personal opinion here: Demand wise you could get way more. (I personally demand value those dogs at 3-4 ‘09 rares each as that is what I personally would be willing to pay for them. Others may not, that so, demand is not set for them.)

Thank you so much, they have edited their trade to this for card dogs, thank you so much.

[Spiritthesly]

I have this trade here

How much should I be adding? Since the Pink September is a list correct??

[SeaCrest]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83922534&userid=851004&signature=A_CKliMK0TDlJl4Oh4CT6g

Is this a fair trade? Thank you in advance.

Unfair to the top by quite a bit.

I have this trade here

How much should I be adding? Since the Pink September is a list correct??

It's a Tier 5 September list, so 26-30 mixed '09 rares, give or take, based on the values in the gaps list. Your side adds up to ~4 '09 rares plus a '15 rare (the rat is a rerelease from July 2009).

[jointedwishes]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83923002&userid=961979&signature=zER5P0ps4CV5wm_nvqCxDg

[helena moonshadow]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83917492&userid=729746&signature=O8ozBwWjAnOuTyiNsQAHTQ
Is this fair? Thank you!