please use new thread!

[Lucien Aeidail]

This is a trade that they offered to me. I know it's currently not fair, but how many '12 commons should there be to make it fair?

Your rare is an '09 re-release. If I did the math correctly, I believe they'd have to add about 51 '12 commons in order for it to be fair.

Thank you so much!!

[Zambeah]

May I please get some help? c:

Do these pets add up to an early 2010 rare/the Smiley rarity wise?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... q0OLZXzzRA

I mean, there are a lot of commons and uncommons, but the oldest pet is a rare November 2010 and I am not sure if they fill the gap inbetween.

I think I'm not supposed to answer this, since I am on the other side of the trade, but if it helps, I believe the gap between an early '10 rare and a late '10 rare is a mid/late '11 uncommon. and I believe my side adds up to about:

64 '14 uc = 32 '13 uc = 16 '12 uc = 8 '11 uc = 2 '11 r (that is without the late '10 rare)

You could get someone else to confirm this if you'd like, since I could be wrong. And, I'd be willing to add more to the trade, as I'd really like to obtain that malk smile and I have plenty of extras to offer.

I believe that this must be correct, I would love to get a 2nd opinion/a confirmation on this though, if possible? c:
I just toally suck at rarity math so I have absolutely no clue about this xD
Thank you very much for your answer/help! c:

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

May I please get some help? c:

Do these pets add up to an early 2010 rare/the Smiley rarity wise?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... q0OLZXzzRA

I mean, there are a lot of commons and uncommons, but the oldest pet is a rare November 2010 and I am not sure if they fill the gap inbetween.

I counted 127 2014 commons worth on their side
Which is about 63-64 2014 uncommons or around 16 2014 rares. Which is worth a 2010 rare. So their side is worth 2 2010 rares or an 09 rare
They are overpaying

[river blossom]

Again I don't know if this is fair demand wise. Any help is appreciated,

[ʟᴏʟʙɪᴛ]

Again I don't know if this is fair demand wise. Any help is appreciated,

Unfair to them, they are offering a main list, demand-wise is up to you and your partner

[See_Air_Ruhh_]

For this trade, I was told it was unfair to me, and that I needed to remove some things. After I removed what I was told I needed to remove, the trade was auto canceled, and they resent this and said "sorry, if you check the date i was already overpaying,
my '08 dog= 2 '09, + 2 '09 = your 4 '09 lions and your 2 '10 '11 and '13 uncommons for a my rares '10 '11 and '13
i'm overpaying with the item and now the '12 dog, but i like lions so it's fine" I had gotten one opinion, but was asked to get another. Is this fair? .-. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... UECKq0PKFQ

I would also like to ask about this trade as well http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 97LbSFkw9Q

Thanks for any help. ^_^

[Zambeah]

May I please get some help? c:

Do these pets add up to an early 2010 rare/the Smiley rarity wise?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... q0OLZXzzRA

I mean, there are a lot of commons and uncommons, but the oldest pet is a rare November 2010 and I am not sure if they fill the gap inbetween.

I counted 127 2014 commons worth on their side
Which is about 63-64 2014 uncommons or around 16 2014 rares. Which is worth a 2010 rare. So their side is worth 2 2010 rares or an 09 rare
They are overpaying

They only offered 102 pets in total? Or did you already converted everything into 2014 commons? c:
Thank you very much for your help! I will count this bid as at least fair then, if not overpay c:

[k.kitten]

. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... RIktRWBARw
Is this fair? I REALLY love the lion PPS ;v; As I don't know which one has more demand.

[ImThatRogue]

For this trade, I was told it was unfair to me, and that I needed to remove some things. After I removed what I was told I needed to remove, the trade was auto canceled, and they resent this and said "sorry, if you check the date i was already overpaying,
my '08 dog= 2 '09, + 2 '09 = your 4 '09 lions and your 2 '10 '11 and '13 uncommons for a my rares '10 '11 and '13
i'm overpaying with the item and now the '12 dog, but i like lions so it's fine" I had gotten one opinion, but was asked to get another. Is this fair? .-. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... UECKq0PKFQ

I would also like to ask about this trade as well http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 97LbSFkw9Q

Thanks for any help. ^_^

I've answered the first one already, I believe, saying that it's slightly unfair to you. And the second trade is unfair to you as well.

[See_Air_Ruhh_]

For this trade, I was told it was unfair to me, and that I needed to remove some things. After I removed what I was told I needed to remove, the trade was auto canceled, and they resent this and said "sorry, if you check the date i was already overpaying,
my '08 dog= 2 '09, + 2 '09 = your 4 '09 lions and your 2 '10 '11 and '13 uncommons for a my rares '10 '11 and '13
i'm overpaying with the item and now the '12 dog, but i like lions so it's fine" I had gotten one opinion, but was asked to get another. Is this fair? .-. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... UECKq0PKFQ

I would also like to ask about this trade as well http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 97LbSFkw9Q

Thanks for any help. ^_^

I've answered the first one already, I believe, saying that it's slightly unfair to you. And the second trade is unfair to you as well.

Yeah, but I know you said I might want another opinion. And for the second one, that's what I was thinking. Thank you.