The "Is this a fair trade" Thread

[Caraxes]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=68758278&userid=209623&signature=EWnrWTvbZKwpgm6VnNwO0g

is this fair? Considering the demand of the zodiacs

[huskypawz]

?? 2017 Commons = 1 '09 Rare

?? 2017 Uncommons = 1 '09 Rare

[pigeon -]

would this be a fair trade? :*
just had a second / third offer i'd like help with to!
and a fourth

[Al3xand3r]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=68758183&userid=792027&signature=0RQTmMxJGhGGM76MM4-NEA

Please help me, is this fair? Thanks!

I think this may be fair, as Malks have demand, and it is much earlier than the very rare, evening it out.

[cocovater]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=68758183&userid=792027&signature=0RQTmMxJGhGGM76MM4-NEA

Please help me, is this fair? Thanks!

I think this may be fair, as Malks have demand, and it is much earlier than the very rare, evening it out.

I think it's fair. A 2016 store pet would be about late 2009/early 2010 rare. As for demand that varies depending of the person.

[spacecatmint]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=68758183&userid=792027&signature=0RQTmMxJGhGGM76MM4-NEA

Please help me, is this fair? Thanks!

I think this may be fair, as Malks have demand, and it is much earlier than the very rare, evening it out.

I think it's fair. A 2016 store pet would be about late 2009/early 2010 rare. As for demand that varies depending of the person.

2016 store pets are worth a mid 2010 rare - it's unfair to them.

[cocovater]

would this be a fair trade? :*
just had a second / third offer i'd like help with to!
and a fourth

I think the third and fourth bids are good. The cinnamon bun goes for 1-2 nons and has quite a good demand (probably about the same as the ur bee). The Aussie is about a non + sorbet and a non is about 3 sorbets so overall they're both good, just preference.
The second bid is good as well if you're an item collector because the malk fairies are worth a '09 rare each, and a full set is about 5-6th advent tier list.

[fennec <3]

I got a trade for longtail and ravenpaw (both 2010's) then they sent me some other animals it was a 2011 but december the 18TH so it was a 2009 then 3 2013's I think I really don't want to trade them but they said its overpay but im not sure

[huskypawz]

I got a trade for longtail and ravenpaw it was a 2011 but december the 18TH so it was a 2009 then 3 2013's I think I really don't want to trade them but they said its overpay but im not sure

Do you have a link?

[fennec <3]

ill try and add the link but if it doesn't work then lol http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... d=68758187