The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Doglike]

I have one bid from my auction:
X
One C$ trade (which I'm no good with):
X
And a bid that needs to be edited. I'm really sorry if this isn't the place to be asking, but what would need to be added to their side to make it fair to me?
X

[NocturnalPanda]

Is this fair?

I think it looks about fair, I'm just not 100% on the exact worth of the store pets..

Looks unfair to you, two of the rare horses could be removed

Thanks! Would you say two of the horses or the one vr horse be removed? (I would prefer to remove the vr horse, but I'm not sure if that has the same worth as two of the rare ones)

[White Fox]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... X6o-8gEsCg

Fair? Not fair? And to which side?
Thanks so much in advance!!

[Vexious]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... HrEzmeF2-A
Fair? Thanks To Whom Answers!

[Takk]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=39536917&userid=91451&signature=S-zGY9vzuSDuX6o-8gEsCg

Fair? Not fair? And to which side?
Thanks so much in advance!!

The two rares and one of the uncommons should be enough

[White Fox]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=39536917&userid=91451&signature=S-zGY9vzuSDuX6o-8gEsCg

Fair? Not fair? And to which side?
Thanks so much in advance!!

The two rares and one of the uncommons should be enough

Ok thank you!

[diana,]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=39544229&userid=630501&signature=_NfDmIb0o7WlHrEzmeF2-A
Fair? Thanks To Whom Answers! :)

Unfair to them. That store pet is only worth C$20, so combined with the others it is worth around C$35, or close to that- I'm horrible with C$. But it's unfair to them.

[Username Unknown]

Red Android (Advent List)

OR

Blue Android (Advent List)

AND
09 VR Valentine's Day 2nd Gen Hyena Dog


AND
09 Malk Horse Plushie (worth a mid 09 Rare/Very Rare according to the official CS item worth thread.)


For:
Dark Gray Tag Husky (Advent List)


Is this fair? What could be added/removed if not?

Thanks for your help,

[Username Unknown]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=39544229&userid=630501&signature=_NfDmIb0o7WlHrEzmeF2-A
Fair? Thanks To Whom Answers!

Unfair to them. That store pet is only worth C$20, so combined with the others it is worth around C$35, or close to that- I'm horrible with C$. But it's unfair to them.

The CNY store pet is worth more than 20 C$ because it's been like 8 months since they were out of store, that means they're worth more than 20C$.

Although Chocco is right about it being unfair to the store pet person. They should be asking for more C$ I think. But I don't know by how much.

[diana,]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=39544229&userid=630501&signature=_NfDmIb0o7WlHrEzmeF2-A
Fair? Thanks To Whom Answers! :)

Unfair to them. That store pet is only worth C$20, so combined with the others it is worth around C$35, or close to that- I'm horrible with C$. But it's unfair to them.
EDIT: Yeah, I guess it is worth more now. But that makes it even more unfair to them.

The CNY store pet is worth more than 20 C$ because it's been like 8 months since they were out of store, that means they're worth more than 20C$.

Although Chocco is right about it being unfair to the store pet person. They should be asking for more C$ I think. But I don't know by how much.