The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[madisong]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83484436&userid=864607&signature=sG_wguk5n-EoKqTC8KbKLQ

Might this be fair?

.

you are over. the uncommons u should take out of the trade

This is false. The other side is overpaying.
Your side is equal to about a ‘12 rare + an ‘18 and a ‘19 rare if you value 2 uncommons at a rare.
Please only give advice if you know the correct answer.

[♥HazelNightmare]

How does this look? They're all WL on both sides, which is nice, though I was hoping to keep some older valuable kids for art? Any thoughts?

I’d like another opinion please

A bit unfair to you, your side comes out to 4 and a half 09 rares , their side is a bit under four 09 rares, that’s converting the 20c$ to a late 2010 rare . They would need about a 2011 rare added to their side .I’ve also seen your 2008 go for some overpay demand wise but that is very subjective as it varies between members.

[Kadmos]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83484436&userid=864607&signature=sG_wguk5n-EoKqTC8KbKLQ

Might this be fair?

.

you are over. the uncommons u should take out of the trade

This is false. The other side is overpaying.
Your side is equal to about a ‘12 rare + an ‘18 and a ‘19 rare if you value 2 uncommons at a rare.
Please only give advice if you know the correct answer.

Thank you very muchy for the answer ^^

I do know the mice is from slumber party event and somehow pets from that event were usually requested more often in the trades i had received. Which is why i was wondering if the demand gives those pets value and the dragons sold during the summer event for 7C$ to 10 C$
May i have just one more opinion about this trade?

[LazyRainwing]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83477131&userid=651521&signature=H-tR5ZtslHjGjTFEbAXBeA

Should I accept this trade??? There both very rare... thx

[♥HazelNightmare]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83477131&userid=651521&signature=H-tR5ZtslHjGjTFEbAXBeA

Should I accept this trade??? There both very rare... thx

The dog is from Feb 2009 and the Elemental is from May 2009 so it’s close to the 3 month rule . They both have great demand but the elementals seem to go for a bit more demand wise. It’s really up to you which you like better as demand is subjective.

[Duckywuckyyy]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83484690&userid=953791&signature=NUGhX4iTGiVpRjyA1d0n9Q

Are they offering a list? Idk if it is a list, but would it be fair?

[lannister]

hey there!
Can I get some help on this one please?
Thanks in advance!

[dissy]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83475596&userid=423217&signature=b4lrs2-xL6BhFTw6k9p_XQ

would this be fair for my blue rose?

[Wrio]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83483450&userid=960136&signature=z-XEy5jN6C7udSflGJfa8w
This? Thanks in advance

[Boneabii]

hey there!
Can I get some help on this one please?
Thanks in advance!

Really unfair to them. Even just one of their 2009 rares would be overpay.