please use new thread!

[qeu9nveq7vn]

unfair to them

How? A bunch of recent releases + a few 2014 very commons/commons don't equal a recent rare.

You would need about 4-5 2014 commons

Hello, is this trade fair to me?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ELpMJyyOew
Thank you!

Not at all, they'd need to add a few early 2014 uncommons I believe, but get a 2nd opinion.

[vincent,]

Guys, please stop spamming the topic. take it to pm if you want. c:

Hello, is this trade fair to me?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ELpMJyyOew
Thank you!

Not at all, they'd need to add a few early 2014 uncommons I believe, but get a 2nd opinion.

I would say it may be near fair. perhaps an uc would make it fair.
around 4-6 UC equal a rare from the same year. they have some early '14 VC and commons in there.
I may be mistaken though, someone had once said that.

[FenFen]

are any of those pets list pets?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... uoGB-f3jLw

[See_Air_Ruhh_]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=45593466&userid=115676&signature=pn1W6F8qiaFDUECKq0PKFQ

Same trade as earlier, it ended up getting canceled after I took off what I was told I needed to take off.
They sent this and said "sorry, if you check the date i was already overpaying,
my '08 dog= 2 '09, + 2 '09 = your 4 '09 lions and your 2 '10 '11 and '13 uncommons for a my rares '10 '11 and '13
i'm overpaying with the item and now the '12 dog, but i like lions so it's fine"

So. I'm confused. .-. I was told I needed to take stuff off to be fair, but they say they are over paying. I need some opinions please. .-.

Unless I calculated wrong, I believe it's actually unfair to you by about an '11 uncommon, not including whatever their item is worth (although I believe their item is worth a '14 common or uncommon). An '08 rare is worth an '09 rare + a '10 rare, not 2 '09 rares. I could have calculated something wrong, so please, get another opinion.

Another opinion please? ^_^

[serik]

are any of those pets list pets?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... uoGB-f3jLw

Nope, only your pet is a list pet and it's only worth 3 '09 rares. This is really unfair to the other side trading you ^^

[nelly,]

are any of those pets list pets?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... uoGB-f3jLw

None of there pets is on any list, but it is very unfair to them
Your Spiderwing BWolf is only worth 3 09' rares
❤

[aden]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 2hhFSiIoKw

[vincent,]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=45597491&userid=22766&signature=zUZOun-a54v32hhFSiIoKw

I'd say its quite unfair to you. yours is older and the UCs don't make up for the years.

[Joof]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=45597491&userid=22766&signature=zUZOun-a54v32hhFSiIoKw

I'd say its quite unfair to you. yours is older and the UCs don't make up for the years.

I would say it is pretty fair. a 12 uc is worth a 14 rare because of the two year rarity gap. 4 Uc of a year equal one rare of that year and i think their uc + c + c$ should add up to a rare

[See_Air_Ruhh_]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=45593466&userid=115676&signature=pn1W6F8qiaFDUECKq0PKFQ

Same trade as earlier, it ended up getting canceled after I took off what I was told I needed to take off.
They sent this and said "sorry, if you check the date i was already overpaying,
my '08 dog= 2 '09, + 2 '09 = your 4 '09 lions and your 2 '10 '11 and '13 uncommons for a my rares '10 '11 and '13
i'm overpaying with the item and now the '12 dog, but i like lions so it's fine"

So. I'm confused. .-. I was told I needed to take stuff off to be fair, but they say they are over paying. I need some opinions please. .-.

Unless I calculated wrong, I believe it's actually unfair to you by about an '11 uncommon, not including whatever their item is worth (although I believe their item is worth a '14 common or uncommon). An '08 rare is worth an '09 rare + a '10 rare, not 2 '09 rares. I could have calculated something wrong, so please, get another opinion.

I hate to post again, but... I just really need another opinion. .-.