The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[LarkinFox]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83477157&userid=950250&signature=zSK6C6svf_ZMPpOh5ZO9aw
Im desprate for an answer Please!!!

Pretty sure that’s an over trade-

[marshsiren]

*item trade
how fair is this trade? thank you for any help (:

xxx

Your penpen plsushie is worth a 2009 rare/very rare by itself. The wings are in the store for 4c$. The other items on your side are worth a common/uncommon from the year they were release not accounting demand,

Their side has 6 medieval plushies which are said to be worth an uncommon/common from their release date but i’ve personally seen go for around a but more than a 2010 uncommon each. The sushi is from the store and worth around 1.75 c$ and the beads are worth a 2012 uncommon/common.

I would definitely say you’re over paying in this trade but please get a second opinion.

[Guest]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83477157&userid=950250&signature=zSK6C6svf_ZMPpOh5ZO9aw
Im desprate for an answer Please!!!

Pretty sure that’s an over trade-

I'm at the other side of the trade, may I have an answer? I want to know what my side and their side can get in terms of lists

[Willow223]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83477157&userid=950250&signature=zSK6C6svf_ZMPpOh5ZO9aw
Im desprate for an answer Please!!!

Pretty sure that’s an over trade-

I'm at the other side of the trade, may I have an answer? I want to know what my side and their side can get in terms of lists

i though the meant i overpaid? im cool with over paying btw

[eckvanet.]

How does this look? They're all WL on both sides, which is nice, though I was hoping to keep some older valuable kids for art? Any thoughts?

I’d like another opinion please

[marshsiren]

Thoughts on this?

I would say Unfair to you due to the rares difference in date, The extra uncommons/commons just dont make up for the date difference

[Willow223]

How does this look? They're all WL on both sides, which is nice, though I was hoping to keep some older valuable kids for art? Any thoughts?

id say its pretty fair... i would do that trade

Thoughts on this?

I would say Unfair to you due to the rares difference in date, The extra uncommons/commons just dont make up for the date difference

i agree

A bid in an auction, how much do you guys think it should be rated? (From 1 to 10?)
Could it deserve an auto?

id say 9 just due to demand, but i would except it 100% though

Is this fair? Thank you! trades/viewtrade.php?id=83476837&userid=9882&signature=mfdc5Ej-QA10geKN37tyOA

NOOOOOOOO OMG THATS WAY UNFAIR TO YOU NEVER EVER DO THAT

[Emi_]

alright guys I need help with this and would love multiple opinions, as I'm greatly considering accepting!

would love a couple more opinions!

[Willow223]

I need urgent help ;w;

ur over, but if ur okay with over than id say it dont matter

alright guys I need help with this and would love multiple opinions, as I'm greatly considering accepting!

would love a couple more opinions!

They are over, but its cool

Fair?

they are over

[marshsiren]

A bid in an auction, how much do you guys think it should be rated? (From 1 to 10?)
Could it deserve an auto?

[/quote
id say 9 just due to demand, but i would except it 100% though

I think it depends, are you still using the rares list? Keep in mind that if your still using the list the collie is worth 7-8 2009 rares nit including any demand if it has any.