The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

Hi there everyone.
Would 2 2008 rare dogs and a second tier Candy Cane horse be fair for a fourth tier string horse?

Thanks for your help. C:

Unfait to the candy cane horse side. The difference between advent tiers is an '09 rare.

Wait, what?
Are you sure?
I've been told differently. Especially when making up two tiers.
Can I have another opinion, please?

agreed unfair to the candy cane horse.

[Acxa]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=20089816&userid=254850&signature=rW0dYYyySYyG04tQSitFWg would this be a good trade up? or is the demand of the drink me out weigh the diffrence in placing on the setember lsit?

Well, the cake dogs have very bad demand, and the Drink Me has quite good demand. Get another opinion

thank you :3

[~Promise]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=20098683&userid=76018&signature=0HEIBgJt_ocp83BC3kZL0g

Does any thing need to be added?

[sylvre]

Is this fair in exchange for
288 VC/Common/Uncommon '12 rats + 18 Uncommon '11 rats + 4 Rare '10 Halloween SpiderRats = 310 rats total?

I'm really looking for an experienced opinion, please.
I don't want either party to be cheated ~ thank you so much!

Okay guys ~ I know this is a complicated trade, but that's why I need help. xD
Could anyone please at least give me a ballpark idea of fairness?
Thank you so much!

[brad!]

agreed unfair to the candy cane horse.

Okay, thank-you.
Do you know approximately how many '09 rares would be fair to make up the two tiers?

[clarabow]

angel advent + shima butterfly wolf + red rose for grapes?
thanks in advance, and if you know how much the side with the angel would need to add (if anything would need to be added) please let me know c:

[Snorrl]

Is this fair in exchange for
288 VC/Common/Uncommon '12 rats + 18 Uncommon '11 rats + 4 Rare '10 Halloween SpiderRats = 310 rats total?

I'm really looking for an experienced opinion, please.
I don't want either party to be cheated ~ thank you so much!

Okay guys ~ I know this is a complicated trade, but that's why I need help. xD
Could anyone please at least give me a ballpark idea of fairness?
Thank you so much!

Unfair to the 310 rat side

[Snorrl]

angel advent + shima butterfly wolf + red rose for grapes?
thanks in advance, and if you know how much the side with the angel would need to add (if anything would need to be added) please let me know c:

I think it's unfair to the grapes

[~Promise]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 83BC3kZL0g
Does any thing need to be added?

[bnom]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/sharetrade.php?id=20098683
Does any thing need to be added?

Wrong link Click 'Share Trade'