"The" Rares List Guide - Do not ask about new UR's!

[BrightPink]

For demand wouldnt it be:
Sunjewel
UR butterwolf
Moonswirl
Dogtag
Banana
UR Cat
July PPS
UR apple
UR horse

Just a suggestion, I dont know much ahaha

The apple just below the PPS? Have you ever seen someone desperately seeking the apple? Nobody wants it.

[Wavesong]

For demand wouldnt it be:
Sunjewel
UR butterwolf
Moonswirl
Dogtag
Banana
UR Cat
July PPS
UR apple
UR horse

Just a suggestion, I dont know much ahaha

The apple just below the PPS? Have you ever seen someone desperately seeking the apple? Nobody wants it.

Well she didn't change that, it was already listed as such...

[Kohaku]

not sure what you mean, the apple is third to last on the list.

[Mana]

Yes I didnt change the bottom ones, Just most of the ones on the top
Also im not sure if the moonswirl would go after the sunjewel or the UR butterfly wolf

[Defying Gravity]

Yes I didnt change the bottom ones, Just most of the ones on the top
Also im not sure if the moonswirl would go after the sunjewel or the UR butterfly wolf

Personally, I see a lot more people wanting the moonswirl over the UR buttefly.

[huskynerd]

I think that list is pretty much unecessary anyway. The main list takes demand into account - on it's own it doesn't mean anything. Last time demand (via wishlists) was factored on it's own it showed the Gray Dragon as the most wanted pet, which clearly does not reflect reality.

[Samurai!]

I think that list is pretty much unecessary anyway. The main list takes demand into account - on it's own it doesn't mean anything. Last time demand (via wishlists) was factored on it's own it showed the Gray Dragon as the most wanted pet, which clearly does not reflect reality.

It's demand and supply mixed together, so the big list is actually a pretty good thing to go off of.

Or did you mean the list Mana suggested?

That's what I thought! xD I concur--CS pets' values can't be listed based on demand alone. Demand plays a large role, but the value supply gives the pet isn't going to be rendered obsolete by it.

[Diabolic]

I think that list is pretty much unecessary anyway. The main list takes demand into account - on it's own it doesn't mean anything. Last time demand (via wishlists) was factored on it's own it showed the Gray Dragon as the most wanted pet, which clearly does not reflect reality.

It's demand and supply mixed together, so the big list is actually a pretty good thing to go off of.

Or did you mean the list Mana suggested?

I think Deja means that the Big list already contains Demand and Supply, so the
little 'extra' list that Mana edited could be removed.

That little list is on the first page of the topic, and probably originates
from the start of the topic when rarity was more taken into the value
than demand.

I too think that the little 'demand' list should be removed, since it is
super inaccurate anyway.

[Wavesong]

I think the UR cat should be equivalent to the Coon Tail on the list now.
Just an observation from recent trades/offers/auctions

[Keatchi]

I think the UR cat should be equivalent to the Coon Tail on the list now.
Just an observation from recent trades/offers/auctions

Did Dec 18th really wear it down that much?