The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Zzyzx1999]

Any thoughts on this trade?

[ChocolateGryphon]

Can anyone help me with this trade?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110916216&userid=361168&signature=Spx6QfwT_4AxWWo_YwBCBA

What should be added/taken away from what side? Thanks so much for any help!

[hinata]

hii i'd like some opinions!! does this seem fair? I believe their side is about 9.5 MA's? i'm not too familiar with the list but I tried my best to calculate

[toxic.love]

Does this trade look fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110905757&userid=55969&signature=q8qjcsXKlDC-hgsyRG19Sg

[piratemolly]

piratemolly wrote:
I really appreciate the help. Can I get feedback on the latest edit?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110798159&userid=315273&signature=N32bejWBWA7aQTIYvriANw

I’d especially like help when it comes to the dark leopard. I value it extra because of the date but i don’t know the going rate right now. Are there store dogs fair?

Thanks in advance.

[alleyway]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110909165&userid=650773&signature=9ET6sMJUBjzNe2IybSyD9Q

help

[harrington]

can someone please help me w/ this trade? i want to accept, but i don't *really* understand how rarities work on cs, especially since the "rares" list was discontinued (it's been a while since i've traded...)

thank you!

[harrington]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110870668&userid=700087&signature=rjkkDLMAsna5xTlrKnI0Cw

im not sure if this bulk trade is fair or not

they're definitely overpaying, it is likely that those token dragons will be very uncommon/rare at the absolute maximum (in my experience).. the 2019 rare alone would be overpay (imo), but i also rarely factor in demand since i can't track it enough so who knows maybe everyone and their mother hates that deer design

[squeegi]

can someone please help me w/ this trade? i want to accept, but i don't *really* understand how rarities work on cs, especially since the "rares" list was discontinued (it's been a while since i've traded...)

thank you!

we cant see the trade! use the link at the bottom so we can see it :)

[Wysterinka]

piratemolly wrote:
I really appreciate the help. Can I get feedback on the latest edit?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110798159&userid=315273&signature=N32bejWBWA7aQTIYvriANw

I’d especially like help when it comes to the dark leopard. I value it extra because of the date but i don’t know the going rate right now. Are there store dogs fair?

Thanks in advance.

I would say they are underpaying. Nonjewel is 1non, swaps for both the tribals that are .5n each (and no their demand won't put them to .25n I never had an issue trading them for this value)
Rest of their offer is 1.4 MA and even RR dark leopard is 2MA so TD is definitely more than that, if you value TD's higher like most people.