The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Faded;]

Red Cerb for UR Bee?

[Heliodor]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=64327594&userid=879657&signature=d2IsVpgy728aQiNsHdWKow
I need to know what a fair trade is for this rainbow wolf :0

Early 2009 very rare=two early 2009 rares
Your '08 dog is actually worth a mid 2009 rare due to extended release. 25C$ is worth an early/mid 2010 rare. The recent rares don't make a difference here. It's unfair to the top

So would removing the recent rares and replacing them with this horse make it more fair, or what would be better?

[Shadow2204]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=64328156&userid=818839&signature=CCiVmq5uRy-W3AirBrMSJQ

is this fair?

UR lion is worth a non + green toxic.
UR Flower is worth 2 sorbets + green toxic. Red toxic is worth a green toxic + balloon dog. 470C$ is worth a speckled rat. The other rares don't matter since it doesn't affect the list placement.
So their side is worth around a non + nonballoon worth. They would need to add around a blue rose or 7 mid advents.

[bee ♥]

^^ thanks!!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ecVPJftlVQ

how about this trade?

[Shadow2204]

Red Cerb for UR Bee?

Depends on how you value the red cerb. Most people value it as 1 non.
The UR bee is worth 2 nons. So if valuing the red cerb as 1 non, then the UR bee is overpaying by a non.

Which should I take?
1?
Or..
2? thanks!

1. UR Aussie is worth 1 non + sorbet. Spotted tribal = 2 sorbs, the other pets don't add up to a sorbet so they would need to add a slightly less than sorbet's worth since their side is worth a non at the moment.

2. UR Aussie is worth 1 non + sorbet. The set of drink me & eat me dogs are worth a non together. So technically, they are underpaying by a sorbet.

^^ thanks!!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ecVPJftlVQ

how about this trade?

Grinner is worth 2 mid advents + an early '09 rare.
They are offering the worth of a little more than 3 mid advents so it's unfair to them.

Is this fair for my auction? I've rated it 5/10, is that good? Tysm

They are offering about the worth of 4 mid advents + a low advent.
It's unfair to the flop eared september dog. They would need to add around 2 mid advents.

[Tortilla]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... SfSXVQksdA

[.crossfire.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=64328407&userid=243000&signature=AOVDmtwciobYSfSXVQksdA

Personally I'd say they're are overpaying. The target can get overpay and the pink Septembers are hard to trade off.
Get a second opinion

[LemonadeQueen]

Is this fair? Ty!

[Tortilla]

Is this fair? Ty!

I'm not sure if it's fair but grinners are really hard to trade off. I just traded 2 for a shima longtail which I know was overpaid by alot but grinners are really hard to get rid of.

[LemonadeQueen]

Is this fair? Ty!

I'm not sure if it's fair but grinners are really hard to trade off. I just traded 2 for a shima longtail which I know was overpaid by alot but grinners are really hard to get rid of.

Oh I know. I've had one before but I ended up trading it away for a blue rose. I know I got lucky XD idk what a grinner is worth so I hope I didn't overpay. Ty for telling me though! <3 very nice