The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread -READ 2ND POST-

[Nebulava]

How fair is this, and how much would they need to add if it's unfair?

[Slowstalker]

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... aoQLKODoQQ

looks a bit unfair to you. vr rats are not high in value, and the store pet is worth around a 2010 rare i believe. the malk dog is worth more

looks like i'm wrong! sorry about that

[Kyar]

How fair is this, and how much would they need to add if it's unfair?

In terms of rarity their side is worth a bit more than a green toxic but not enough to get up to the next tier. So in that sense it would be unfair to you by around an UR lion + nonballoon or so. However quantity advents and septembers are in pretty good demand right now so I would say that adding more than a non to their side wouldn't make it a very good deal for them. It's up to you and your partner to decide how much overpay/underpay (respectively) you're comfortable with but that is my take on it. :)

Edit:

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... aoQLKODoQQ

looks a bit unfair to you. vr rats are not high in value, and the store pet is worth around a 2010 rare i believe. the malk dog is worth more

In terms of rarity they're overpaying a pretty good amount. And to be honest I have the same rat and have actually had numerous offers on it - it seems pretty popular all this considered. That being said rats generally take a bit longer to get a fair trade. I would still say unfair to them overall - their side is pretty dang close to if not bottom-line advent value.

[HockeyVictoria]

I know it's unfair to them rarity wise but how is the demand of the Winged Wood Angel compared to the Red-X
As in which has better demand.?

[Kyar]

I know it's unfair to them rarity wise but how is the demand of the Winged Wood Angel compared to the Red-X
As in which has better demand.?

To be completely honest there's no logical way to compare demand here. The WWA is worth more than double the red-x so the value difference doesn't really work when comparing demand. What I mean is the red-x has pretty good demand while the WWA is pretty average but I've still never seen anyone offer so much for the x and you could get more with the WWA.

[[dys]functional]

Is a trade with a Green Grinner fair for a set of 2010 Punk store dogs?

[Bloom & Katt]

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ACTEQBJ5fA
Thanks!

[Nebulava]

How fair is this, and how much would they need to add if it's unfair?

In terms of rarity their side is worth a bit more than a green toxic but not enough to get up to the next tier. So in that sense it would be unfair to you by around an UR lion + nonballoon or so. However quantity advents and septembers are in pretty good demand right now so I would say that adding more than a non to their side wouldn't make it a very good deal for them. It's up to you and your partner to decide how much overpay/underpay (respectively) you're comfortable with but that is my take on it.

Thank you very much <3

[lyxa]

Is this fair demand-wise? Thanks in advance! ^^

[Kyar]

Is a trade with a Green Grinner fair for a set of 2010 Punk store dogs?

Unfair to the punk dogs. You could get a white loltia and one of the others plus about 2 09 rares for the grinner or if you added an 09 rare or two to the grinner you could get the orange, pink, and yellow ones.

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ACTEQBJ5fA
Thanks!

In terms of rarity it's probably pretty close to fine but the malk fire wolves are pretty tough to find and tend to go for a bit more than face value. :) I'd say it's a bit unfair to you in that sense.

Is this fair demand-wise? Thanks in advance! ^^

Rarity unfair to them. Demand… I think you'd probably be better off with your side unless you're planning on keeping the UR cat. :)