The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[sylvre]

I was told in the previous thread that this is unfair to me.
Could someone please tell me what I should remove on my side to make it fair?
Thank you very much!

[Fat Unicorn]

I was told in the previous thread that this is unfair to me.
Could someone please tell me what I should remove on my side to make it fair?
Thank you very much!

Yeah, that's unfair to you.
The 2008 rat should be worth around 2 early 2009 rares, the tess horse is worth a mid 2009 rare, unsure about the VR 09 Giraffe rat (my bet would be a early VR 09 dog at best) the VR BHA horse should have like a mid 09 rare.. umm.. other than that, 3 month radius for the other pets minus the bats.

Get another opinion though.

[Lynke]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Vz3fojI4uQ

Help please :3

[Draoslo]

Is this fair?

What does a copper/green malk dragon usaly go for?

Thank you!

[daz]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=20081077&userid=346209&signature=fE6siSN-QGAuVz3fojI4uQ

Help please :3

fair, and i SLIGHT overpay.

[Shire98]

I was told in the previous thread that this is unfair to me.
Could someone please tell me what I should remove on my side to make it fair?
Thank you very much!

Yeah, that's unfair to you.
The 2008 rat should be worth around 2 early 2009 rares, the tess horse is worth a mid 2009 rare, unsure about the VR 09 Giraffe rat (my bet would be a early VR 09 dog at best) the VR BHA horse should have like a mid 09 rare.. umm.. other than that, 3 month radius for the other pets minus the bats.

Get another opinion though.

i agree^

[Fat Unicorn]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=20081077&userid=346209&signature=fE6siSN-QGAuVz3fojI4uQ

Help please :3

I'd say fair, since the dragon is a tess one, and the gap is larger than 3 months but then the rarity of the dog kinda makes up for it, I suppose.

[sylvre]

Yeah, that's unfair to you.
The 2008 rat should be worth around 2 early 2009 rares, the tess horse is worth a mid 2009 rare, unsure about the VR 09 Giraffe rat (my bet would be a early VR 09 dog at best) the VR BHA horse should have like a mid 09 rare.. umm.. other than that, 3 month radius for the other pets minus the bats.

Get another opinion though.

i agree^

Thank you very much, both of you!

Does this look any closer to fair to both parties?
Thank you again to whoever can help, I really appreciate it. <3

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

Is this fair?

What does a copper/green malk dragon usaly go for?

Thank you!

seems unfair to you.
the green ones usually go for mid-late 09 rares. maybe more for demand. copper ones go for midish-early 09 rares, and maybe more considering demand.
rarity wise that may be close to fair, but none of their pets have very good demand besides scourge

[Fat Unicorn]

Does this look any closer to fair to both parties?
Thank you again to whoever can help, I really appreciate it. <3

You could remove everything from your side except for the reindeer horse & one bat, I suppose. ^^