The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[miskit]

I'm not sure if the 2009 rare robot dog has any demand, is this a fair offer? I was going to accept it but I wanted to make sure first

[redpandasareLIFE]

Between the rares? trades/viewtrade.php?id=98672920&userid=804027&signature=i8ucCRVxFrMWoRu1TDAEWA

Their side -
Rare warrior cat - 0.5 MA
2021 common
2021 very common

Your side -
2010 rare Malk PPS cat - worth 3 month rule
2021 common
2021 uncommon

It seems like they are significantly overpaying. The 2010 rare doesn't have huge demand like the warrior cats do. It can usually get overpay for being a Malk and a PPS... but it doesn't actively trade for 0.5 MA like the rare warrior cat.
Please get a second opinion though because I could be missing something. I couldn't find any trade data for the 2010 Malk PPS cat.

Thank you so much! May I please get a second opinion?

[regular;]

how does this look ?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98673225&userid=714665&signature=XTv9X0nzq1fFQT899wRvjw

[Dreams of Roses]

Link
Would you take this? I am a little nervous to trade away most everything I have but I do like the eat me/drink me

UR Kirin = 2-2.5 nons
UR S'more = 1.5-2 nons
Green Toxic = 0.25-0.5 nons
Seal PPS = 0.75 nons each = 2.25 nons
Light Speckled Rat = 0.25-0.5 nons
TD Hollyfox Dog = 0.25 nons
Carousel Horses = 2 MA each = 4 MA
2012 Fluffy Store Dogs = 1 MA each = 3 MA
Roadkill PPS = 1-2 MA
Jack o Lantern Rat = ~0.5 MA (little data)(sources: XXX)

nons: 6.5-8
MA's: 8.5-9.5 = ~0.75 nons
total: 7.25-8.75 nons

[Ghōst]

I'd like to know how fair this is? I'm not too knowledgeable on C$.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=98675597&userid=792268&signature=FzXA6rPZLyFL-L0Bn_OxWQ

[Dreams of Roses]

I'm not sure if the 2009 rare robot dog has any demand, is this a fair offer? I was going to accept it but I wanted to make sure first

someone on the pet worth thread asked about the robot dog, too, hearing it may have special demand. if there is special demand, there's no consistent way to tell how much more it's worth, so any added value due to demand is up to the users.

[Aktori]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98673211&userid=737315&signature=Uicqx_Nm_UAaDeBJUvcRLA

Is this fair? Thank you

[goofer goblin]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98673211&userid=737315&signature=Uicqx_Nm_UAaDeBJUvcRLA

Is this fair? Thank you

i wouldn't say totally fair, but close.
sunjewel trades for 3-3.5 non, while ur cat trades for 2.5-3 non <3

[winx]

I'm not sure if the 2009 rare robot dog has any demand, is this a fair offer? I was going to accept it but I wanted to make sure first

The Silver Robot Dog is worth the three month rule, so fair swap for an 09 rare. Any additional demand is up to you and your trading partner.

They are offering -->
3 2010 rares = 1.5 09 rares
+ 2021 uncommon + 2022 store pet (equivalent to an early 2011 rare, 0.25 09' rare)
Total:
1.75 09 rares on their side + 2021 uncommon

[Ghōst]

I'd like to know how fair this is? I'm not too knowledgeable on C$.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=98675597&userid=792268&signature=FzXA6rPZLyFL-L0Bn_OxWQ

bump