The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Doberman Pinscher]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83914383&userid=169112&signature=xc4dRqNf15uZzHuLwLScEQ

What could be added to their side to make this fair, in terms of 08/09 rares? I don’t really know what the striped September is going for now.

[polyphon]

is this fair? thanks for any help <3
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83916260&userid=373031&signature=UcHhMTEwjd-Ztra0F4I-jw

And this?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83916305&userid=373031&signature=fGLX-Clm8bYs3m_13TATnw

[makenshi]

This looks awesome but im not sure if its fair demand wise?? :O

[alchemist.]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83863794&userid=447893&signature=2N6h7meitL6kM4IMy_lejw

Thanks in advanced!

[ArisuV]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83919263&userid=375783&signature=j9GKNyVdtqzfPYVAOU5fsw

I don't like this one, personally, but I'm not entirely educated on year rarities and such. Would this be fair..? I don't want to get cheated or cheat them-
If it isn't fair, how do I fix it?

I'm only good with rarity for rarity, not the years ^^; Thanks!

[SeaCrest]

Thoughts on this? trades/viewtrade.php?id=83911335&userid=5378&signature=xg4Q-sMbWUYQAXUsfx8New

[Rbpuppy]

This looks awesome but im not sure if its fair demand wise?? :O

I don’t believe any of those pets have super high demand, except maybe the Collie.

[maleficent.]

fair? I know the grinner and the Tess horse aren’t that good in demand, but I also know that the rat isn’t either. If unfair, what is it that would need to be added to make it a bit more fair? Thank you

[Doberman Pinscher]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83863794&userid=447893&signature=2N6h7meitL6kM4IMy_lejw

Thanks in advanced!

2 2012s would equal a 2011 technically, so it’s slightly unfair, but it is ultimately up to you. I would personally accept just because of the amount.

[LordDarkMist]

Is this fair, if not how can it be made fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83907193&userid=614219&signature=96oAPFkvSq1Y5Yaf4pDVIw