The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[SunRaes]

Hi! Would you guys personally accept this?
Plains Zebra = Coontail
I know that, rarity wise, the Zebra is worth 3 Nons + a Blue toxic, and the Coontail is two nons, but I'm talking about demand. Would you guys personally accept?
Any and all help is appreciated!

[Puptarts]

0/10
7/10
6.5/10
7.5/10
Add on to bid 4
5/10
3/10
How fair are these and what would you rate them? Should I take any of these?

Thank you to everybody who responded! I also got this trade
Should I accept this?

the sunjewel is worth 5 nons and they are asking for just that - which may be more depending on where the fox gets placed.
i wouldn't call this a good trade for you because the fox could be placed above the nons and the sunjewel usually doesnt get its full value.
i wouldn't say its fair since there is no way to know with the fox still not on the list but personally i wouldn't accept
get a second opinion on this though^^

[Myst_c]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78979441&userid=929053&signature=yKeVKV0mXE6a7kPqTF3fZg

??

[Audrey_Bee]

Hi! Would you guys personally accept this?
Plains Zebra = Coontail
I know that, rarity wise, the Zebra is worth 3 Nons + a Blue toxic, and the Coontail is two nons, but I'm talking about demand. Would you guys personally accept?
Any and all help is appreciated!

personally i wouldn't, the zebra tends to get about a nons worth demand wise, the coontail is valued at 2 nons, although it very very rarely gets traded down fairly.
zebras have quite bad demand whereas the coontail doesn't really have good or bad demand, its just not really..wanted?? or looked for, but most players tend to avoid zebras. get a second opinion though as this is based off of my opinion and my view on their demands

[AuroraButterflyx]

Hi! Would you guys personally accept this?
Plains Zebra = Coontail
I know that, rarity wise, the Zebra is worth 3 Nons + a Blue toxic, and the Coontail is two nons, but I'm talking about demand. Would you guys personally accept?
Any and all help is appreciated!

hmm, the plains zebras is very difficult to trade off, i trade mine off around non to 1.5 nons. My friend was able to get a raven with her coontail. I would take the coontail however, might want to get a 2nd opinion. The coontail is easier to trade off but kinda hard to trade off for 2 nons, 1.5 nons will be easier to trade off

[Astellia]

Hi! Would you guys personally accept this?
Plains Zebra = Coontail
I know that, rarity wise, the Zebra is worth 3 Nons + a Blue toxic, and the Coontail is two nons, but I'm talking about demand. Would you guys personally accept?
Any and all help is appreciated!

Don't take my word for it but I would accept simply because I've been looking for the plains zebra all over the place.

Realistically, the plains zebra has been known to be hard to get rid of as it's not valued as high as it technically should be.

[skybristle]

Someone messaged me saying they'd offer a red toxic for my rerealese BMD.
Is it fair? It still might not happen, since i prefer the BMD.

[SunRaes]

Alright! Thanks to all those who helped me! ^^

[Kaminarii]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78981740&userid=857986&signature=WuwnazUg1vlrbiXfSNjtZQ

Fair?

[warriorcatlover1122]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78981732&userid=330689&signature=iVFxntG4z0W1uIktgKmRSA

Is this trade above fair? am i over paying on my end? Im not sure. Yes the trade says cancelled but i plan on resending it as a uneditable trade if its fair