The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[dry]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97767240&userid=830020&signature=ZXib5DliUqwDj48EHQjzZg
trades/viewtrade.php?id=97769030&userid=830020&signature=wOLGNwNACmF5KIj4NQBriQ
which one is a better offer?

[angelberry]

Trade 1
Trade 2
Which one of these offers for my item collection is worth more? Any input is greatly appreciated.

i would get a second opinion, but i would say the first one due to the fact that all the store pets are at least worth a '10 or '09 rare, and they included older rares as well. i think the PPS store fox has more value as well due to demand.

[Pastel-Axle]

Trade 1
Trade 2
Which one of these offers for my item collection is worth more? Any input is greatly appreciated.

i would get a second opinion, but i would say the first one due to the fact that all the store pets are at least worth a '10 or '09 rare, and they included older rares as well. i think the PPS store fox has more value as well due to demand.

Thank you, can I get a second opinion?

[Sapphic Software]

Is this fair?
Also this

[far]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97723047&userid=985305&signature=3nu8gMc9cbm1Vl_5SrwJ7w
Please somebody help me, i've been asking since yesterday

The camo green October is worth the 3 month rule (It's a 2008 rare) And the other 3 pets are just '09 rares with seemingly no additional value. If you believe that 1 '08 rare = 2 '09 rares they are overpaying. I don't believe the camo dog has any special demand and I would personally accept.

[Sapphic Software]

Is this fair?
Also this

[*Nevi Nova*]

is this trade fair? its a small trade; however i am not good when it comes to items worth ;^^

[far]

Is this fair?
Also this

1st: The 2019 store pet is worth an early '10 rare. In my opinion the 2012 uncommon and 2021 rare don't close the gap to equal your '09 rare.
2nd: I couldn't find any special value with the nick pps so I'm assuming it's worth the 3 month rule. the 2010 rare is enough for it alone, they are overpaying with the rest of the pets.

is this trade fair? its a small trade; however i am not good when it comes to items worth ;^^

The UR Foal is worth 1-1.5 non (seems to get 1 non more often) The Pink Bunny seems to be worth 3 '09 rares and the Deerskin Outfit does not seem to equal a non (more like 1-2 MA). This looks very unfair to you.

[Free Shade]

Thoughts on these 2?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97768661&userid=459121&signature=mMVZSAgzvUcQnFZgMKX7bg

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97768669&userid=459121&signature=B8En77Y1SIRA3iQVGExHmg

Both for my raven dog though I'm fairly certain the 2nd is unfair?

Thanks for any help!

Also, would an Eat Me be a fair swap for the Raven?
I'm not sure the worth/demand of the two compared to each other

[dry]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97767240&userid=830020&signature=ZXib5DliUqwDj48EHQjzZg
trades/viewtrade.php?id=97769030&userid=830020&signature=wOLGNwNACmF5KIj4NQBriQ
which one is a better offer?