The "Is this a fair Trade?" thread.

[Lockpick]

I get a lot of trades asking for these two pets:

not necessarily together, but at least 2 trades requests every day for each of them.

The only pets I really need/want are the '08 Octobers (spots, stripes, and the camouflage dog). A couple of the people offering do have the pets I'm looking for. However, I know that the rating system is somewhat flawed, or maybe just not segregated enough.
The PPS, while marked "uncommon" and seemingly highly sought after (judging from the masses of trades I get), can be quite easily found. And the "uncommon" Octobers, being older, must be worth more. But how much more?
Also, the rat is marked rare, but I wouldn't say that they're overly uncommon. (if that makes any sense) XD

Assuming they've chosen a couple "very common" to "common" filler dogs from the last few months to bulk up my end, what would be fair to ask? One October? 2 Octobers?

[KyoshiYan]

o.o I'm missing that rat :3 I would offer two octobers for the rat since it is the harder to get of the pumpkin rats. the pps red panda... no idea. *goes to message*

[Tif + Jo]

Which is rarer because im debating.

Is a Black eyed galaxy rarer than a raccoon tail?

No, The raccoon tail is, in my opinion, much sought after and there are fewer of them, I believe, than the black eyed galaxy. The person with the Galaxy would need to add a bit more to make it fair.

[BB-1313]

is this a fair trade

for this

[Yukinstrüdel]

is this a fair trade

for this

I would say not for the owner of the bunny.

[Shy]

This:


For (Mine):


They're the one sending the trade, so an early reply is much appreciated ^^

[Yukinstrüdel]

This:


For (Mine):


They're the one sending the trade, so an early reply is much appreciated ^^

Well, it depends on if what you're trading is a duplicate or not, and whether the one they're trading is one you already have or not. I would say the yours is way cooler, and probably a bit rarer, but not by tons.

[Theophilus]

From what I get, both of those are the same rarity - all the staff dogs are. So thereforeit would just matter on if you had a duplicate of the Malk and / or wanted the Masquerade pup.

[Rocka_Boo]

Would a Non Jewelery Sun be worth a Sunback and Non Coon Tail Dog?

Thanks ^.^

Anyone?

[Carm]

Would a Non Jewelery Sun be worth a Sunback and Non Coon Tail Dog?

Thanks ^.^

Anyone?

Hmm.. I think the sunback + non-coon offer is a little too much.