The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Farewell!]

Can I get an opinion on this trade please.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... D7kHONTsrg

Thanks

Unfair rarity wise

Any idea what I should add or remove?

[LemonadeQueen]

Was this fair?

I'm pretty sure that was unfair to you demand wise

What do you mean? I thought the Malk element cats had very high demand.

It was unfair to the other side. Your dog was from February 2009 so just their rat would have been a fair swap, the cat is overpay. The malk cat is from "09 and usually goes for overpay depending on who you trade with. I say it was a good deal <3 I see the Elemental Malk cats go for 2 "09 rares each so either pet alone would've been fair for your dog.

[ruel]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... IIL5m7CG4g

Please help! Is this fair?

[Bastiodon]

Is this fair? I want to trade my rares for bulk common <3 http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... gn_iwUFOCA

Unfair to you rarity wise

Thank you! Second opinions?

[karachi]

Any idea what I should add or remove?

Maybe ask them to add decent demand old items on their side

[the trickster]

I know I have asked several times, but my sister doesn't know whether to accept or not, because she doesn't know if she can get the same pets for it again.

Is this fair? I want more opinions so I know if she should accept.

[stanxeno]

is this fair? i have no idea what rarities are for items :')
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... lSts1emfoQ

[evilpineapples]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66341480&userid=885005&signature=6ptosZbkDChYIIL5m7CG4g

Please help! Is this fair?

I believe this is unfair to you, someone correct me if I'm wrong but the 2008 dog had an extended release until 2009, the cat on your side is overpay

[LemonadeQueen]

I know I have asked several times, but my sister doesn't know whether to accept or not, because she doesn't know if she can get the same pets for it again.

Is this fair? I want more opinions so I know if she should accept.

They're overpaying by about a sorbet. It's up to her if she wants to accept or not. If she prefers the moon swirl over her pets then she should accept, if she likes her pets better then she should decline.

That's the best I can say buddy <3 if she wants to accept she can and they'd be overpaying so she'd get a good deal (imo).

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66341480&userid=885005&signature=6ptosZbkDChYIIL5m7CG4g

Please help! Is this fair?

I believe this is unfair to you, someone correct me if I'm wrong but the 2008 dog had an extended release until 2009, the cat on your side is overpay

Agreed. I'm pretty sure that just your dog would be a fair swap <3

[zant.]

is this a fair trade? Both the horse and husky are in the same advent tier but I'm not sure about demand so I added an '08 pet.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... i0aHnrr71A

Thanks in advance

please help c: