The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Dang It Moon Moon!]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73834524&userid=774851&signature=6apgz4NoKl2UkSWJOuigYQ

Is it already fair, if I'm overpaying, how much would they need to add? ( The item is from '09 )

Unfair to them.The store pet is worth a late 09 rare and the item is worth a 2011 uncommon.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73817446&userid=907615&signature=113HoXu_qvKD3nY-0pSSbA


Thank you in advance! Is this fair?

I don't know about the Walkman but rarity wise it's fair. The 2015 store pet is worth a late 09 rare and your's are worth a mid 2010 rare each ^^

[Animall]

*QUANTITY TRADE AHEAD* Hi! Can I get some mega help with this trade?
I’m so tempted due to the sheer amount of quantity, but I’m not sure of the value of their side.

With just the lists, their side adds up to about 4-ish nons (valuing the zebra at 1 non) plus the rares which (I'm guessing) value adds up to about a low main list (I counted about 54 09 rares making each 09 vr worth 2 09 rares plus there are all the other rares I was too lazy to count)
I hope this helps some c:

That does help, thanks so much!
Can I have some personal opinions? Would anyone personally accept this trade?

[Dang It Moon Moon!]

*QUANTITY TRADE AHEAD* Hi! Can I get some mega help with this trade?
I’m so tempted due to the sheer amount of quantity, but I’m not sure of the value of their side.

With just the lists, their side adds up to about 4-ish nons (valuing the zebra at 1 non) plus the rares which (I'm guessing) value adds up to about a low main list (I counted about 54 09 rares making each 09 vr worth 2 09 rares plus there are all the other rares I was too lazy to count)
I hope this helps some c:

That does help, thanks so much!
Can I have some personal opinions? Would anyone personally accept this trade?

I can only tell from what I have seen it go for: As far as I have it's been going for 3-5 nons.

[myth;]

*QUANTITY TRADE AHEAD* Hi! Can I get some mega help with this trade?
I’m so tempted due to the sheer amount of quantity, but I’m not sure of the value of their side.

With just the lists, their side adds up to about 4-ish nons (valuing the zebra at 1 non) plus the rares which (I'm guessing) value adds up to about a low main list (I counted about 54 09 rares making each 09 vr worth 2 09 rares plus there are all the other rares I was too lazy to count)
I hope this helps some c:

I can only tell from what I have seen it go for: As far as I have it's been going for 3-5 nons.

If it were me, I'd not trade my skelebun for those pets. Though the quantity is tempting and a few of the pets have good demand and are true dates, the other lists (like the zebra, tess horses, rats, line tribal, and butterfly wolves) may be difficult to trade fairly in the future. But that's just my personal opinion. And the Skelebun had traded for up to 6 or more nons, there is a few trades linked in the Rares List thread to prove that.

[Fransii]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73828099&userid=772304&signature=VzGLEIcSBeJsdwTQzNvjRQ

[Julia]

Does anyone know whether this trade is fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73834437&userid=4163&signature=hZcsKeKNDVxReqHxYoHFug

And I'd love to get a second opinion on this one, too:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73744073&userid=4163&signature=5vKfu90hUDAMa8lekzemHA

Thank you in advance! Help is appreciated!

[sinpai]

Need help please
can anyone tell me if this is fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73834121&userid=915619&signature=2GEqBeDtGFY7NgPQDjmfyg
Thank you

unfair to you, their pet is worth only 30-35 c$

Given that a 2015 store pet is worth a late 2009 rare, which is worth 40C$ or more, it's a fair trade. From that perspective at least.
.

The C$ guide says 30-35 even for late 09 rares, only mid & early 09 rares are worth 40 C$ so still unfair to the C$ side, please do not correct me with false statements

[cleodora soleil <3]

is this fair?
i really want those two tree dogs

[The Plague.]

is this fair?
i really want those two tree dogs

They'd need to add another 2018 rare. 2 rares of 1 year = a rare of the last year

[cleodora soleil <3]

is this fair?
i really want those two tree dogs

They'd need to add another 2018 rare. 2 rares of 1 year = a rare of the last year

thanks!