The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[nicole]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97110646&userid=982241&signature=gHhnJvEQvBPDj3eqsPKNLg

Can i get an opinion on this trade? and if it's not fair, do i have to add to my side or their side?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97112454&userid=982241&signature=-HIgOodS55ZjSLwIkL0MA

and what about this one?

For the first trade, it's unfair to you as a 2017 store pet is worth 1 09 rare and your side is about 1 09 rare and a 2010 rare as 2018 store pets fetch 1 09 rare and 2019 pets fetch 1 2010 rare.

For the second trade, you sent the wrong link so I can't check atm ):

is that fair for joker dog?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=97110138&userid=994729&signature=YdlDzMZYvj2r9fNw48mwww

help her

Dog Plushie: 1 MA
Hammer: .25n
Nails: .25n
Red Cloth: .25n
Gold Cloth: .25n
Wizard Token: .25n-.5n
Raven Perch Order: 2 MAs
---> Item Guide Link (: = https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/ ... edit#gid=0


Their side is about 1.5n-2n however the demand of these items are actually not the best. You would have a hard time struggling to trade this all down unless you're looking to complete your item collection and you need these items still. I would stick with the Joker.

[_Eleanor_]

Could I please get some help with this regarding demand?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=97110932&userid=1017271&signature=5nNbYxyTQDuudsV-NVJVcQ
An with this one in general?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=97113083&userid=1017271&signature=bFHKRJOobBBZHN8yJP8_Jw

[Draconica2014]

]. trades/viewtrade.php?id=97098213&userid=878037&signature=qugg_MRtz9RVidR6I5ZNkg

this? tysm for help

[El.]

Hi I have been trying for a bit to get some opinions on this bid:

click here

If I am valuing my 5 Alpacas at 6-9 2009 rares each (low MA to MA each), would this be fair to me? What does their side add up to (especially with items?)

I am going to try to do my own research and keep it updated here, but I would love opinions from anyone who has traded any of these, or even just if anyone feels like this is generally fair or not? Thank you to all in advance!

MY SIDE:

• Alpaca Store Pony Set (2013)
• Value: ~ 5 MA/.5 non

THEIR SIDE:
[wip]

• Gray Fairy Item = 09 R
• Red Fairy Item = 09 R
• Dog Plushie = ????
• Treble Berries = 09 R
• Fairy Goat 2012 Store = 1 MA
• 5 2020 Store Pets
• 3 2019 Store Pets
  (including PPS Lion store pet 2019)
• 2018 Store Pet
• rare PPS Lion (2016)
• 2 2010 rares
• 3 2009 rares
• Value = ???

MA COUNT:

1. red fairy item + gray fairy item + 3 09 rares + 2 2010 r = 1 MA
2. treble berries + 5 2020 store + 3 2019 store = ?
3. lion pps + 2018 store pet + dog plushie= ?
4. fairy goat = 1 MA

[/quote][/quote][/quote]

[Mocking~Jay]

up

[Inkspiration]

Don’t know the names of most of the pets that were offered so don’t know how to look it up… Android store cats

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97111185&userid=254337&signature=eHoTSNodrU-v1sDqdQ8evQ

[nicole]

Don’t know the names of most of the pets that were offered so don’t know how to look it up… Android store cats

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97111185&userid=254337&signature=eHoTSNodrU-v1sDqdQ8evQ

This is unfair to you as your pets are worth a low advent each, or 4 09 rares and they're offering 3 09 rares + 1 09 rare in c$ (:

[XxTheCatQueen]

is 2KC$ for holly dog fair

[Rbpuppy]

Out of curiosity, what is their side valued at? I’m not familiar with the UR on their side either.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97095377&userid=42960&signature=bGWuCxiwXXgK8xx0kxLlzg

Thanks!

[nicole]

is 2KC$ for holly dog fair

It is but it's not the best to get c$ for list pets as c$ is really hard to trade off as there's too much in circulation and not many people are looking to sell other lists for c$. So I would really only take it if you really needed the C$ ! ;D