The "Is this a fair Trade?" thread.

[Cirque]

UR Butter Bunny

For:

Blue Sept 08 Rat [R]
Pink Sept 08 Rat [R]
Camo Sept 08 Dog [U]
Watermellon Dog [R]
Green 3-tail Sept 08 [U]
Black Stripe Advant Rat [R]
Red Husky Advant [R]
Pink Advant Dog [R]
Skull 08 Rat [R]
Santa Rat [R]
Nick PPS dog [R]
Red CS 1 year PPS [R]
Purple CS 1 year PPS [R]
Pink Shima B-wolf [R]
Ice PPS [U]
Malk Newbown [Unknown]
Unborn 18+ day Rats. [Unknown]

Anyone?

i'd say fair

[Santa Ria]

My deal is it seems like a bunch of pets not many people [at least the people I trade with], would want...especially for my wishlist pets.

[KyoshiYan]

then don't argue go for it XD

[Santa Ria]

then don't argue go for it XD

I said most people wouldnt want silly.

[KyoshiYan]

I thought you meant the rats and stuff were yours.

[Delta.K]

i would say that its rarer or not dependeng on if you like the pet a lot or a little

[phantom_werewolf]

I need a bit of help.

Trade 1

Trade 2

Are either of these fair and if not, how should I edit them to make them fair? I only have one spare of some of these pets and I don't know if I should trade them yet or wait until they grow up to see how rare they are. And, in case anyone is wondering, I don't have any of the pets being offered so I would be interested in owning them. I'm just not sure if the pets being asked for are worth it.

Anyway, I've got to leave for work so if you could PM me an answer that'd be great. Or I can just check here when I get home. Thanks in advance for the help.

[christa renz]

For trade 2 i'd say not fair, not sure about the first.

[Eucliwood]

I need a bit of help.

Trade 1

Trade 2

Are either of these fair and if not, how should I edit them to make them fair? I only have one spare of some of these pets and I don't know if I should trade them yet or wait until they grow up to see how rare they are. And, in case anyone is wondering, I don't have any of the pets being offered so I would be interested in owning them. I'm just not sure if the pets being asked for are worth it.

Anyway, I've got to leave for work so if you could PM me an answer that'd be great. Or I can just check here when I get home. Thanks in advance for the help.

I'd say you're being ripped off in both of them. The first trade has common pets in that you could get from an adoption center, and the second is trying to milk you out of your newborns... I'd say cancel both, unless they have something you're interested in.

[Atwood]

The first one I would say is fair enough if you're looking for those dogs, since neither of the pups seem particularly uncommon at this point. There is the chance of multiple outcomes to consider, but it's not a really bad trade. The second one is not fair at all, since it's only offering a couple of recent pets that are easy to get for a much larger number of pups, including several that might be highly sought later (Shima's long-tailed pup and the Gatoh pup). I would advise just cancelling the second one, but the first is more up to you - you could probably swap out one of the adults for a slightly more uncommon version, but it looks fairly balanced to me as it is.