The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Neoncherry64]

Is this a fair trade? I'm leaning towards a no-

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95191318&userid=1007779&signature=2Xb0kR8wCXnOIU8b1i8BQg

It is impossible to say if this is fair or not before rarities are announced. Generally though, token pets do tend to turn out rather than the free event pets, so I wouldn’t take this trade. Trading unknown pets is always a gamble, and nothing is ever guaranteed to turn a certain rarity though.

[skyrunner17]

Is this fair? I'm hesitating but also wanted another opinion.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95212804&userid=229554&signature=iaSCbtS-V2ZUZgSy53bizg

[Rbpuppy]

Is this fair? I'm not good with bulk trades like this https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95220301&userid=908566&signature=8ocb5yiLw9Xyvxpyll8wpA

you’re pretty over. you have multiple ‘10 rares on your side + a 2010 vr + other year rares.

I agree. All you would need to make this fair is 4 2010 Rares and a 2021 rare (assuming the dog becomes a rare)

[_Eleanor_]

Heya,
could someone please give me a hint on if these two trades are fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=95170516&userid=1017271&signature=7H_pMJoVQsuqeM7vRv1zbg
trades/viewtrade.php?id=95176033&userid=1017271&signature=lTiQII1Ru7E7c3d3f6_RAQ
Thanks a lot!

Still would be glad to have some advice! Also on this one
trades/viewtrade.php?id=95230047&userid=1017271&signature=xh-m--NnjrXLWEdRstDtog

[tatilucia]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95232578&userid=74655&signature=DVgE5hSNB1_XP5cMNsdZ8g

Help? I love the horse, but turkey!!

[EditPink]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95233603&userid=902320&signature=lKwZwDIHTDsDetzfDZuytg

not really interested in this but is it fair

[MewSefet]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95232578&userid=74655&signature=DVgE5hSNB1_XP5cMNsdZ8g

Help? I love the horse, but turkey!!

Slightly unfair to you if you follow the 3 month rule. Your pets are both older by around 9 months, I would potentially add a '10R onto their side

Heya,
could someone please give me a hint on if these two trades are fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=95170516&userid=1017271&signature=7H_pMJoVQsuqeM7vRv1zbg
trades/viewtrade.php?id=95176033&userid=1017271&signature=lTiQII1Ru7E7c3d3f6_RAQ
Thanks a lot!

Still would be glad to have some advice! Also on this one
trades/viewtrade.php?id=95230047&userid=1017271&signature=xh-m--NnjrXLWEdRstDtog

Trade 1 (their pets, your tokens): completely depends how you value tokens. If you value at C$2 each (generally accepted token value for this event), this is unfair to you by 2x 2020C/2x2021 UC. However, with the end of the event very near, most people have already gotten the majority of pets that they want for the event, so token demand is getting lower. I personally would take this trade if I had all the event pets that I wanted.

Trade 2 (their pets for your event pet): hard to tell for sure without rarities. I would safely say reasonably fair if not favouring your side - particularly if that pet ends up being an UC

Trade 3 (all event pets): hard to tell, the horses cancel each other out as it is same litter (at least while rarity is unknown) and same with the raptor + pps pup (free pet for free pet). As for the crystal dig pets, I've seen a bit of variation in the value of this between 1 crystal + 3 crystals per dig pet. if you value 1:1 dig pet and crystals then it would be fair, if not, they may need to add another crystal token pet to their side

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95233603&userid=902320&signature=lKwZwDIHTDsDetzfDZuytg

not really interested in this but is it fair

The 2012 store B-wolf is valued at around 1MA (8x09R), the two dogs that they are trading are both Low Octobers valued at just under 0.5 MA ea (3x 09R), which brings their total to a little under 1MA (6x09R) which favours your side by about 2x 09R. I'm not 100% sure about the demand for these pups though, so might be worth getting a second opinion (source x).
Summary: Not completely unfair, favours your side (2xdogs)

[unloxed]

hi needing some help
trades/viewtrade.php?id=95235051&userid=917224&signature=7DH5Ug-ourX3yJanrSUgHA

[MewSefet]

hi needing some help
trades/viewtrade.php?id=95235051&userid=917224&signature=7DH5Ug-ourX3yJanrSUgHA

I would say fair, if not favouring your side
They've added the equivalent of just over 1x'18R on their side to compensate the 9 month difference between the 2018 rare pets on both sides

[shinx.]

unsure if this is the place to ask so my bad but does anyone know how much
c$ would need to be added on their side to make this fair?
thank you in advance!